|
Illuminism
German
and Italian Illuminism
The greatest exponents of Illuminism were French
and English. However, Illuminism also spread to
Germany and Italy, although in these countries it
did not meet with such widespread development.
Germany and Italy accepted Illuminism, but took
from it only those principles which were most in
conformity with the cultural tradition of these
nations. Thus Illuminism was prevalently religious
in Germany, and practical in Italy.
German Illuminism
Germany, involved as it was in religious wars
during the seventeenth century, did not participate
to any great extent in the general European
cultural movement during that turbulent period.
Leibnitz, and after him Christian von Wolff, who
edited and gave Leibnitz' works wide dissemination,
linked Germany once more with the general current
of the new culture. For Wolff, a Rationalist and a
formalist, philosophy had to concern itself, not
with concrete reality but with the "essences" of
things; for only the "cogitable" belongs within the
limits of philosophical knowledge. For Wolff the
"cogitable" is logical possibility, and is utterly
immune from contradiction. Such dogmatism and
formalism were widely accepted by the German
schools; Even Kant himself, in his pre-critical
period, was an ardent follower of Wolff.
Under the influence of Locke's and Humes's
empiricism, a reaction tending toward the study of
psychological analysis began to take place. Even
Leibnitz spoke of "obscure and confused"
representations, which would be mysterious forms of
life but not yet ideas or intellectual
representations. It was toward this new sphere of
thought that the new inquiries directed themselves,
and in so doing they cast light upon a new field of
culture, namely, art and the enjoyment of the
beautiful. The proper faculty of art was held to be
"sentiment," the activity of which would be on a
middle ground between the theoretical and the
practical. Alexander Baumgarten (1714-1762)
introduced a new term -- "aesthetics" -- to
indicate this new field of study. Thus in Germany
there already existed the beginnings of the
Romantic movement which was to supersede
Illuminism.
By the middle of the seventeenth century a new
religious movement called Pietism appeared
in Germany. Pietism, a reaction against Protestant
dogmatism and its obstinate opposition to other
religions, minimized the importance of dogma and
placed special stress upon subjectivism and
sentiment.
In religious questions, German Illuminism was
divided into two opposing currents of thought. The
first of these currents, positivist and
rationalist in character, sought to
demonstrate the perfect agreement between
revelation and reason. According to the
Positivists, what was obscure and confused in
revelation assumed clear and distinct form in
philosophy. Exponents of this trend of thought were
Moses Mendelssohn (1729-1796) and the many
publications of the time appearing under the name
of popular philosophy. The second current of
pietistic thought was negative, and essayed,
through critical study, to destroy revelation as
something false, impossible and contrary to reason.
This thesis was advanced by H. Samuel Reimarus
(1694-1768) in his Apology.
The most representative German thinker of the
period was Gotthold Ephraim Lessing (1729-1781),
poet, philosopher, historian and author of
Education of the Human Race by Divine
Revelation. Lessing maintained that the effort
of a search for truth is of higher value than the
actual possession of it -- a teaching that later
passed into Romanticism. Lessing wrote:
- If God should hold all truth in His right
hand, and in His left hand only the aspiration
to truth, under the condition that the seeker
must eternally err, and He should say to me:
'Choose,' I would rush upon the left hand with
humility, and I would say: 'Father, I have made
the choice; pure truth is for Thee alone.
History, and religious history in particular,
has a progressive and relative value. Progress in
history brings Lessing to a consideration of
religious history even prior to the Old Testament.
He maintains that history, from the earliest times,
is not a fabric of errors, prejudices and deceits,
as the Illuminist holds, but a history of the
education of a people by means of revelation, which
progresses from the simpler to ever more elevated
and perfect forms.
Italian Illuminism
Illuminism was imported from France into Italy,
where it spread over the peninsula at the same time
that Locke's empiricism and Newton's physics were
gaining wide acceptance. Proof of Italian interest
in Illuminism exists in the fact that the
Encyclopedia was printed in Italy in 1758 and again
in 1770. The predominance of French sensationalism
is also due in no small measure to the influence of
Condillac, who was tutor at the ducal court in
Parma for ten years. Nevertheless, the need for a
critical revision of sensationalism soon made its
appearance among Italian thinkers.
Antonio Genovesi (1712-1769), Empiricist and
sensist, although accepting the data of experience
as a starting point, suggested that experience be
subjected to the criticism of reason, since reason
alone is able to coordinate the data furnished by
the senses. This is a tendency to turn sensism
toward Rationalism.
Italian Illuminists were especially concerned
with practical, economic and legislative problems.
The principal centers of culture were Naples and
Milan. In Naples, besides the above-mentioned
Genovesi, we find Pietro Giannone (1676-1748), who
gave himself over to the task of establishing the
supremacy of the rights of the state over those of
the Church. Departing from the field of philosophy
into that of theology, he was not immune to error
and heresy. Nicola Spedalieri (1740-1795), a priest
of the province of Calabria, tried to show that the
"rights of man" advocated by the French Revolution
had already been proclaimed by the Gospel.
In Milan Cesare Beccaria (1738-?1794) wrote
Tratto dei Delitti e delle Pene (Treatise on
Infractions and the Penalties), and Pietro Verri
(1728-1797) found Caffe (Café), a
politico-literary review. These men promoted the
reform of many laws, including the abolition of
torture, which was still in use as a means of
punishment, and they prepared the way for the
"Risorgimento." This was a movement toward national
unification among the many states of the Italian
peninsula; it culminated in the establishment of
the kingdom of Italy under the house of Savoy and
was completed by the seizure of the Papal states in
1870. During this period Giovanni Battista Vico
(1668-1744) lived in Naples. Vico, however, is not
to be numbered among the Illuminists; he was an
exponent of universal culture.
Return to
The Philosophy of Illuminism
Go to
The Philosophy of English Illuminism
Go to
The Philosophy of French
Illuminism
|
Lessing's
Philosophy of Religion and the German
Enlightenment,
by
Toshimasa Yasukata
The
Intellectual Roots of the Italian
Enlightenment,
by
Vincenzo Ferrone
|