|
Select: Averroes (Ibn
Roshd) -- Muhammad Iqbal
Averroes
(Ibn Roshd) - (1126 - 1198)
Main Ideas:
- Philosophy does not contradict the revealed
Law of Islam.
- Rule by one or a few is better than rule by
many.
- Because the understanding of the mass of
people is limited, the revealed Law speaks to
them indirectly.
- Recondite questions of faith should not be
discussed in public.
Important Works:
- The Decisive Treatise
- The Incoherence of the
Incoherence
- Commentary on Plato's Republic
- Middle Commentary on Aristotle's
Rhetoric
Due to a mistake made in translating the work of
Mohammed ibn Ahmed ibn Mohammed ibn Roshd from the
Arabic into Latin, this great Islamic philosopher
for about two centuries deeply influenced Christian
thinkers, by whom he was known under the name
Averroes (picture).
Averroes was a Spanish-Arab philosopher, the
most noted Aristotelian scholar in Islam. Called
the "commentator" by Thomas Aquinas, Averroes
composed 38 treatises on the various works of
Aristotle, as well as original tracts on astronomy,
physics, and medicine. His primary work was The
Incoherence of the Incoherence, a spirited
defense of his neo-Platonic and Aristotelian
philosophy.
Averroes studied medicine and law, then served
as a judge in Seville and later at Cordoba. In 1182
he became chief physician to the Almohad caliph Abu
Yaqub Yusuf, whose favor he enjoyed until Yusuf's
death, in 1184. His religious views were considered
heretical by orthodox Muslims, however, and he was
banished from the court by the caliph Mansur in
1195. He was recalled from exile in 1198 but died
soon after.
Averroes taught that there is one eternal truth
which, according to the various levels of
education, can be formulated and comprehended in
two ways, namely, the way of revelation, by the
Koran, or the way of natural knowledge, with the
aid of Aristotle and other philosophers.
Averroes' philosophy represents a continuation
of the Hellenizing traditions of al-Farabi and
Avicenna; his commentaries on the Greek
philosophers were noted for their clear analysis.
Although he enjoyed a high reputation in the Muslim
world of learning, he was more influential among
Christian and Jewish philosophers. The guiding
principle of all his writings was that philosophy
and religion must agree. He viewed philosophers as
prophets who teach the same principles as religious
prophets but in a higher, more abstract form.
He maintained on occasion that there is a double
truth, and that a proposition may be theologically
true and philosophically untrue, and vice versa.
Christian Averroism flourished in the thirteenth
century, especially at the University of Paris
where Siger of Brabant was the leader of that
school. In 1277, Averroism was condemned by the
Church. Averroes also influenced Jewish
philosophers of the Middle Ages.
Apart from his ascendancy over Christian and
Jewish philosophy, Averroes has become important as
the last great philosopher of Islamic Spain, and as
the last and greatest of all Arabian Aristotelians.
He studied medicine and jurisprudence, and was a
judge in Sevilla and Cordova. Although he was fully
acquainted with the natural sciences, his approach
to philosophy was determined to a great extent by
his legal training. As a jurist, Averroes insisted
on the literal meaning of religious and secular
documents, and was eager to refute
misinterpretations, particularly those which were
advanced by theologians. In this way, Averroes
studied, explained and annotated Aristotle whom he
glorified as a "man chosen by God."
The writings of Averroes survive mainly in Latin
and Hebrew translations. His theories of the
evolution of pre-existent froms and of the
intellect anticipated modern concepts.
In The Radical
Academy
Muhammad
Iqbal - (1873 - 1938)
Main Ideas:
- The restoration of Muslim glory begins with
a rational understanding of the destiny of human
beings and will follow their spiritual ascent,
which will culminate in the perfect order.
- Muslims can truly attain spiritual salvation
if that salvation is both individual and
social.
- History is not the reflection of Divine will
and therefore its course can and ought to be
changed.
- Islam ought to be interpreted rationally,
doing away with purely mystical and scholastic
approaches to religion.
Important Works:
- Secrets of the Self
- Mysteries of Selflessness
- Message of the East
- Persian Hymns
- Six Lectures on the Reconstruction of
Islamic Thought
- Book of Eternity
- Gabriel's Wing
- Gift of Hijaz
Muhammad Iqbal was born in Sialkot, Pakistan. He
studied law and philosophy in Europe (1905-08) and,
on his return to India, taught philosophy and
literature, practiced law, and soon achieved fame
as a poet. He achieved fame through his poetry,
whose compelling mysticism and nationalism caused
him to be regarded almost as a prophet by Muslims.
The British knighted Iqbal in 1922 in recognition
of his poetry.
Iqbal became active in Muslim politics, serving
as a member of the Punjab Legislative Council
(1926-30) and president of the Muslim League
(1930). One of the first to advocate a separate
Muslim state in India, he has been called the
spiritual father of Pakistan, where the anniversary
of his death (Apr. 21, 1938) is a national holiday.
His efforts to establish a separate Muslim state
eventurally led to the formation of Pakistan.
His prose work, The Development of
Metaphysics in Persia, is one of the first
modern non-polemical Muslim texts reflecting
Western scholarly methodology. Most of his works
are in Persian and Urdu poetry, inspired by
classical Persian mystical poetry, especially that
of the great Persian mystic Jalal al-Din Rumi
(1207-73). Iqbal's most accomplished poem, the
Persian The Secrets of the Self, is a modern
reaffirmation of Islamic philosophy's widely held
epistemological principle of the primacy of
intuition and experience by the self-cognizant "I,"
or "knowledge by presence."
|