|
Select: Bahya ibn Pakuda
-- Judah Helevi --
Berachyah
Judah ben Samuel of
Regensburg -- Maimonides
Bahya
ibn Pakuda - (c.1050)
Main Ideas:
- Demonstrated a pure conception of God, unity
and attributes.
- Basic principle of ethics is thankfulness to
God, for His creating the wonderful world.
- The goal of religious conduct is love of
God.
Important Works:
- Hobot ha-Lebatot (The Duties of the
Heart)
- Torot ha-Nefesh (Doctrines of the
Soul)
Little is known of the personal life of Bahya
(ben Joseph Ibn Padudah Bahya), except that he was
a dayyan (judge at the rabbinical court) in
Saragossa toward the end of the eleventh century.
His book, Hobot ha-Lebatot (The Duties of the
Heart), expressed his personal feelings more
elaborately than was usual for the Middle Ages. It
depicted the noble, humble soul and pure,
imperturbable mind of a man ever-grateful to God,
motivated by his love of God.
Bahya regarded the soul elevated toward God and
liberated from the shackles of earthly existence as
evidence of purification, communion with God as the
ultimate goal. However, his teachings neither imply
nor result in neo-Platonic ecstasy. He remained
faithful to the Bible and the Talmud. Unlike many
other schools of mysticism, he differentiated
between man and God.
Although a religious moralist, he resolutely
subordinated moral righteousness and lawful action
to the pious contemplation of God, for the latter
served as the most effective control of egoistic
instincts and passions.
Judah
Helevi - (c. 1080 - 1141)
Main Ideas:
- In the quarrels of the metaphysicians there
is evidence of the inherent uncertaintly of
philosophy.
- The roots of metaphysical uncertainty lie in
human nature; all merely natural striving after
God is finite and incomplete.
- Only where God actively descends to reveal
His will can uncertainty be overcome; but the
God of the philosophers dwells above,
unmoved.
- These differences between religion and
philosophy are reflected in the attitude toward
God assumed by their followers.
- The philosopher makes God a mere object of
contemplation, whereas the follower of Abraham
strives for passionate communion with God.
- The truly good life is not philosophic
contemplation but that immedate and
super-rational relation with God achieved in its
highest form by the prophet.
- For the ordinary man the good life consists
in prayer, good works and the love of God.
Important Work:
- Kitab al-Khazari (The Book of
Argument and Proof in Defense of the Despised
Faith)
Judah Helevi grew up in Islamic Spain, traveled
widely, and, led by an intense Jewish nationalism,
set out for the land of Israel. Evidence points to
his death in Egypt, although according to legend he
was trampled at the gates of Jerusalem.
As a "flaming pillar of song," Judah Halevi (or
Jehudah Hallevi or Judah ha-Levi), the greatest
Jewish poet of the Middle Ages, was exalted by
Heinrich Heine, who, himself an undeniable expert,
sensed through the medium of a translation of
Halevi's mastership of versification and his
fervent soul. He has not only exerted a strong
influence on Heinrich Heine, but also on various
Jewish authors.
Halevi sang of love and friendship, of virtue
and beauty, and most passionately of the fate of
the Jewish people, of Zion and God. Several of his
sacred poems form part of Jewish prayer-books in
every country where Jewish congregations exist. His
approximately 800 surviving poems include love
songs, eulogies, and religious works.
But Helevi was also an important philosopher of
religion. His Kitab al-Khazari, written in
Arabic and translated into Hebrew under the
Title Sefer Ha-Kuzari (Book of the Khazar),
referring to the conversion to Judaism of the
Khazar King Bulan II (c. 740), is a defense of the
Jewish faith against Christian and Islamic attacks
and at the same time, a profound meditation on
Jewish history and an acute demarcation between
philosophy and religion.
The close connection between the revealed
religion and the history of the Jewish people is
characteristic of Halevi's position. He maintained
that Judaism does not center in the person of its
founder as the religions of Christ and Mohammed do
but in the people to whom the Torah has been given,
and he goes so far as to declare: "If there were no
Jews there would be no Torah." But he by no means
idolizes his people in the way modern nationalists
do. Jewish history is the work of Divine Providence
which he regarded as the continuation of the Divine
creative activity.
Halevi was opposed to Aristotelianism which he
reproached for subjecting the Deity to necessity
and for being incompatible with the idea of a
person God. Platonic tradition seemed more fitting
to him, for he was inclined to regard God as the
principle of form that moulds the eternal material
principle. Fundamentally, however, Halevi remained
reluctant to use philosophical categories in
matters that concern religion, and he often
expressed his dislike of philosophy and
philosophers, although he proved to be one of
them.
In The Radical
Academy
Berachyah
- (c. 12th or 13th century)
The literary fame of Berachyah is chiefly
founded upon his Mishle Shualin (Fox
Fables). Some of these were of his own invention;
others were derived from the fables of Aesop, the
Talmud, and the Hindus, but even in the adaptation
of plots to his own Hebrew style, he displayed
poetic originality and narrative talents. The
best-known of his philosophical works, encyclopedic
in quality, is Sefer Hahibbur (The Book of
Compilation). Here, he developed the ideas of
Saadia, Bahya Ibn Pakuda, and Solomon Ibn Gabirol.
He was versed in the eastern and western branches
of Jewish philosophy, and was well acquainted with
medieval French and English literature.
The personal life of Berachyah is solely
conjecture. He was called Berachyah Ben Natronai
Hanakdan. His father's name indicates descent from
the Jewish scholars of Babylonia, which may help to
explain Berachyah's knowledge of Hindu stories. His
surname means "punctuator," probably an allusion to
his profession of scribe or grammarian. There is no
agreement as to the time, place, or country in
which he lived. Some of his biographers assume that
he wrote during the twelfth century; others during
the thirteenth century. Some maintain that he lived
in Provence; others in Northern France, and still
others in England. It is not improbable that he was
an itinerant teacher, scholar, and writer.
In The Radical
Academy
Elsewhere On The
Internet
Hahasid,
Judah ben Samuel of Regensburg -
(12th & 13th centuries)
The Hebrew word Hehasid, means "the
Saint." Judah's co-religionists revered him because
he was an extremely pious man, absorbed in mystical
contemplation, a great teacher, scholar and a
careful leader of the Jewish community of
Regensburg where he settled in 1195. He was the
initiator of Jewish mysticism in Germany, a way of
thinking and feeling that is different from
cabalistic mysticism because it insists more on
prayer and moral conduct.
Judah denied all possibility of human
understanding of God. Man must fulfill his
religious duties, as they are prescribed in the
Bible, without reasonable knowledge of the
Almighty, but, by purification, obedience to
ceremonial life and asceticism, he may obtain union
with God that is beyond reasoning. In this way,
Judah tried to reconcile the demands of orthodox
Judaism with enjoyment of mystical exstasy.
Judah's biography is adorned with many legends
which testify to the admiration of his
contemporaries and succeeding generations. He wrote
Sefer Hasidim (Book of the Pious), and
Sefer Hakahod (Book of Glory). The second
book has been lost. It is known only by quotations
other authors have made from it.
In The Radical
Academy
Elsewhere On The
Internet
Maimonides
- (1135 - 1204)
Main Ideas:
- Neither biblical creationism nor
Aristotelian eternalism is demonstrable.
- Creation, however, is more probable and
preferable theologically.
- Creation can explain the difference God's
act make in the world and can rely on God's
freedom to explain how multiplicity emerges from
sheer divine simplicity.
- The fundamental demand of revelation is that
we pursue the human likeness to God by
perfecting humanity in ourselves.
- Philosophy is universal, but the moral
prerequisites of intellectual receptivity and
the material perquisites of prophetic creativity
make true prophecy rare.
- Pagan religions are primitive,
superstitious, or perverse.
- Islam and Christianity, which have spread
monotheism throughout the world, preparing for
the Messianic age, are derivative from Israelite
prophecy.
Important Works:
- Commentary on the Mishnah
- Book of the Commandments
- Mishneh Torah
- Guide to the Perplexed
- Regimen of Health
Among the rabbis of the later Middle Ages and
centuries thereafter, an adage was current, saying,
"From Moses to Moses there is none like unto
Moses." It means simply that Maimonides (Moses ben
Maimon) (picture) is to
be regarded as the greatest figure in Jewish
history since the man who delivered the Ten
Commandments to the Jewish people. In fact, the
spiritual development of Judaism up to the present
age is incomprehensible without taking account of
Mainmonides' activities as a codifier, judge and
commentator of the Bible and the Talmud.
This outstanding medieval Jewish philosopher was
physician to the Sultan Saladin and communal leader
of Egyptian Jewry, as well as an important figure
in the codification of Jewish law. His formulation
of the basic principles of Judaism in a series of
13 creedal affirmations, in the hope of clarifying
the differences between Judaism and both Islam and
Christianity, occasioned great controversy when it
was first composed; it has since been accepted
widely and incorporated into most Jewish prayer
books.
His Mishneh Torah (Copy of the Law), an
organization of Jewish oral law, also became
enmeshed in controversy, partly because of its
rigorously systematic rearrangements of traditional
rabbinic law, and partly because Maimonides did not
indicate the sources on which he based his
decisions concerning correct interpretations, thus
seeming to claim excessive authority for
himself.
The greatest controversy, however, developed
over Maimonides' major philosophic work, Moreh
Nebukhim (Guide for the Perplexed), in which
Maimonides attempted to interpret many biblical and
rabbinic themes in the light of the philosophy of
Aristotle as known to him through the Arabic
philosophers al-Farabi and Avicenna.
An important element in his undertaking was to
supply allegorically philosophic translations of
the anthropomorphic expressions used with reference
to God in many biblical passages. This departure
from literal reading of the sacred text was deeply
resented by many of the religious leaders of the
age.
In some contexts Maimonides was ready to abandon
his Aristotelian commitment -- for example, with
regard to the eternity of the world, because this
doctrine in his view restricted God's absolute
freedom of will to create or not to create the
world.
Among the many other works of Maimonides are
replies to queries in which he attacked the claims
of astrology and condemned the attempts to
calculate the time of the coming of the Messiah.
Maimonides displayed his scientific turn of mind in
ten treatises on medical subjects; recent
translation and studies indicate that as a
physician Maimonides was within the tradition of
Hippocratic medicine, but advanced for his time. He
was particularly forward-looking in his stress on
preventive medicine, as shown in the work
Regimen of Health.
In The Radical
Academy
Enrich
Your Life With a Philosophy Book...
Enrich
Your Life With a Philosophy
Magazine...
|