|
Select: Joseph Solomon
Delmedigo -- Moses Hayim
Luzzatto -- Baal
Shem-Tov --
Benedict Spinoza --
Moses Mendelssohn
Joseph
Solomon Delmedigo - (1591 -
1655)
A restless spirit makes Delmedigo (picture)
the prototype of the wandering Jew. He traveled
from Candia, Crete, his native town, to Padua,
Italy; thence to Egypt, Turkey, Poland, Hamburg,
Amsterdam, Frankfort, Worms, and then finally died
in Prague. He earned his living either as physician
or teacher but wherever he sojourned, he remembered
to study the natural sciences.
He was a disciple of Galileo and a keen critic
of the medieval philosophy of nature; but he had to
be careful, lest the ecclesiastical and secular
authorities were offended by his ideas. He was
shrewd enough to avoid such disturbances. His only
known works are: Elim (Palms) dealing with
matematics, the natural sciences, and metaphysics,
and some letters and essays.
In The Radical
Academy
Elsewhere On The
Internet
Moses
Hayim Luzzatto - (1707 -
1747)
Some occurrences in Luzzatto's life show a
parallel to that of Spinoza. Just as Spinoza earned
his living by grinding optical lenses, Luzzatto did
the same by grinding lenses. Like Spinoza, he was
ex-communicated from his co-religionists. But
Luzzatto remained a faithful Jew, ardently devoted
to the cause of Judaism. He even felt himself, like
the Messiah, bound to rescue the Jewish people from
danger and misery, and he believed that the study
of the Kabbalah would enable him to perform that
mission.
From 1727 he claimed to hear a voice revealing
heavenly secrets. Eventually he was accused of
Sabbatian heresy and witchcraft. In 1743 he set out
for Israel, where three years later he and his
family perished in a plague.
Notwithstanding pressure on the part of orthodox
rabbis, Luzzatto did not turn his thoughts from the
mysticism that not only incited his loftiest
aspirations but also inspired him to the conception
of high ethical principles.
Luzzatto was a versatile and gifted writer whose
Hebrew style is much admired. He composed a drama,
many liturgical poems and philosophical treatises
in Hebrew, while his mystical works were written in
Aramaic. His best-known book is Mesillat
Yesharim (Path of the Upright) which has been
compared with Bunyan's Pilgrim's Progress though it
was not influenced by the latter. His poetry and
plays occupy a transitional position between
medieval and modern Jewish literature.
In The Radical
Academy
Elsewhere On The
Internet
Baal
Shem-Tov - (1700 - 1760)
Israel ben Eliezer (picture)
was born in Ukraine. Little is known of his life,
and that little is encrusted with legend. Many of
the legends closely parallel the stories that have
clustered around the lives and activities of
Christian saints.
After seven years of solitary meditation, Israel
ben Eliezer began to teach, in 1740, a mysticism
which later became known as Chassidism. This earned
him the title of Ball Shem-Tov (Master of the Good
Name), even though in his early years he had been
despised by his people as an ignorant and
inefficient man.
He taught that the divine spirit is omnipresent
in each man and in everything that exists.
Therefore, it is possible to serve God in even the
most trifling of actions. In contradistinction to
other schools of mysticism and to various Jewish
mystical doctrines, he declared that the pleasures
of the senses are not sinful, because man must
serve God with his body as well as with his
soul.
In reaction to the intellectualism and casuistry
of the rabbinical legalists, Baal Shem-Tov stressed
the joyous and enthusiastic experience of religious
participation. Song and dance, fervent prayer, and
ecstatic communion with God are the keys to unlock
spiritual powers. To complete the list of cardinal
virtues, he added humility to the virtues of
joyfulness and enthusiasm. He emphasized the
elements of adherence (devekut) to God through a
recognition of the divine immanence in nature.
Attainment of this adherence demanded the total
concentrated devotion (kavvanah) of the person in
fervent communion with God.
In his teachings, all things, including the
lowest acts, had dignity. Although he did not
reject learning, he put prayer above scholarship,
insisting that his followers pray "with gladness"
and forget, through religious concentration, all
the sufferings imposed by life.
The teachings of Baal Shem-Tov gained a large
number of adherents among the Jews of Eastern
Europe who, at that time, were subject to frequent
persecutions and whose economic situation was
constantly growing worse. These people were
impressed by his kind and humble personality and
revered him as a saint. He received gifts of
immense value, but ended each day by distributing
all his wealth among the poor. He saved many
co-religionists from despair, enabled them to
endure extreme hardship, and imbued them with the
spirit of confident piety.
In The Radical
Academy
Elsewhere On The
Internet
Benedict
Spinoza - (1632-1677)
An expanded version
of the philosophy of Spinoza is presented
HERE.
Main Ideas:
- The Absolute or God is substance, which has
two attributes: thought and extension.
- Substance is constituted by its attributes
or the ability of the intellect to perceive the
essence of thought. It is actual and
eternal.
- Attributes are the essences of substance,
the essence of God perceived by the intellect
which expresses the substance.
- Modes are modifications of the substance;
the individual substance is a mode of God.
- God is known through pure thought.
Important Works:
- Cogitata metaphysica
- Ethics
- Tractatus politicus
- Tractatus de intellectus emendatione,
Letters
Spinoza (picture)
was born in Amsterdam, of Jewish-Portuguese parents
in good circumstances. He pursued theological
studies (Hebrew literature) at his father's wish
but found little in Jewish theology that satisfied
him. He renounced Judaism and was excommunicated
from the Jewish faith in 1656. He was forced to
leave Amsterdam and he settled at The Hague in
1669, making his living by grinding lenses. He
lived a simple and unselfish life, and his writings
aroused intense interest and considerable
indignation. The Elector Palatine, Karl Ludwig,
offered Spinoza the professorship of philosophy at
Heidelberg with the condition that he remain
reasonably orthodox. Spinoza declined to accept it
because he preferred to assert his independence of
thought. The majority of his works were not written
under his own name because of the strong charge
made concerning his supposed atheism. His period of
great production was from 1660 to 1677. He died at
The Hague in his 45th year, a poor and persecuted
man.
Of the two questions left unsolved by Descartes,
Spinoza aimed to resolve the relationship between
the infinite and finite substance by affirming the
unity of substance. The relationship between the
soul and the body was dogmatically affirmed in
virtue of the psycho-physical law.
Substance, Attributes,
and Modes
Spinoza holds that substance (the concept of
which has no need of the concept of any other in
order to be conceived) is one. The two
substances of Descartes ("res cogitans" and "res
extensa") are attributes of a single substance.
This single substance is God conceived of as
Natura naturans; from this proceeds
"Natura naturata," the world of men and all
things, which are infinite modifications (or
modes) of the infinite attributes.
The laws which govern Spinoza's substance
are:
- Mechanical necessity: God is not free
in the process of His modifications;
- Psycho-physical parallelism: the
series of phenomena pertaining to extension are
parallel to those pertaining to thought.
Man and
Ethics
Man is a derived mode of the attributes of God;
the spirit is a mode of the attribute of thought,
and the body is a mode of extension. Man's
activities are three, and to each one there is a
corresponding moral perfection:
- Sensible cognition: man is governed
by passions;
- Rational cognition: man enjoys
tranquility and contemplation of the universal
order of the world;
- Intuition: man enjoys the
intellectual love of God.
Politics
Spinoza maintains that society arose from a pact
made by man, who at first lived in the state of
irrational nature. Force and violence used by
authority are irrational but necessary means for
the advent of rationality. If the subjects are more
rational than the sovereign, the state will fall in
order to give place to another more rational.
Importance of Spinoza's
Philosophy
It is important in three aspects:
- As a system of pantheism;
- In it application of the geometrical method
to Ethics;
- In its presentation of the identity
hypothesis as the theory of knowledge -- objects
are the embodiment of thought. (If we know God's
conception of things we know God as he is.)
Spinoza's system did not meet with good
reception at first, perhaps because it was not
understood. Idealism took it over because it found
in it the principal lineaments for a metaphysics in
the idealist sense.
Summary
The Absolute or God is substance which has two
attributes: Thought and Extension.
Substance is constituted by its attributes
or the ability of the intellect to perceive the
essence of thought; it is actual and eternal.
Attributes are the essences of substance,
the essence of God perceived by the intellect which
expresses the substance. Modes are
modifications of the substance. The individual
substance is a mode of God. God is known through
pure thought.
In The Radical
Academy
Elsewhere On the
Internet
Moses
Mendelssohn - (1729 - 1786)
Main Ideas:
- Adduced proofs of the immortality of the
soul and of the existence of a personal
God.
- Distinguished beauty from metaphysical
perfection, arguing that the latter is unity in
multiplicity, known in its purity only to God;
the former is a human substitute based on our
introducing an artificial uniformity into those
objects we perceive as wholes.
- First to advocate the social emancipation of
the Jews, to plead in Germany for the separation
of church and state, and for freedom of belief
and conscience.
Important Works:
Moses Mendelssohn became a major figure in
German philosophy and literature while remaining
faithful to his Jewish heritage. Thus he encouraged
those, both Jewish and Christian, who believed that
Jews could accept modern Western culture without
apostasy. Although he was a contemporary of
Immanuel Kant, Mendelssohn cast his philosophic lot
with the "academic" expositors of the philosophy of
Leibniz, especially Christian Wolff.
In the late seventeenth century, Father Pierre
Bonhours, a Jesuit and a refined art critic,
published a pamphlet in which he held that a German
could never be a poet or an artist, nor could he
understand aesthetical problems and phenomena. Of
course, the booklet aroused indignation in Germany,
and provoked violent counterattacks. At that time,
however, Frenchmen and Germans agreed that a Jew
could never become integrated into modern culture,
let alone contribute to its development.
This opinion remained constant until, by 1755,
the surprising news was spread in literary circles
that there was in Berlin a Jew named Moses
Mendelssohn who could not only speak and write
German flawlessly but who could discuss
philosophical and literary problems and was even
esteemed by Gotthold Lessing, the most feared
German critic of his time, as an authority in
aesthetics and psychology.
Many otherwise independent thinkers would simply
not believe that the news was true. Some of them
went to Berlin in order to gaze in astonishment at
such a curiosity. Then, for some years, even
Mendelssohn's sincere admirers, such as Kant and
Lessing, expressed doubts that he could continue to
be devoted to German culture and at the same time
remain loyal to Judaism. Later they recognized that
he could do both.
Mendelssohn enriched descriptive psychology by
his treatise on mixed sentiments. His essay on
evidence in metaphysical sciences was awarded a
prize by the Prussian Academy against his
competitor, Immanuel Kant. His Phaedon
(1767), defending the idea of the immortality of
the soul, was a favorite book of German Jews and
Christians alike for more than two generations. In
his essay Jerusalem (1783) he first defended
the separation of religious and political
authority, and then argued for granting full civil
rights to Jews. This work deeply impressed Immanuel
Kant, who became convinced that Judaism was a true
world religion.
Mendelssohn also translated the Hebrew Bible
into German and demanded civil rights for the Jews
as well as the separation of Church and State. With
him came the beginning of a new epoch in the
history of the Jews, not only those of Germany.
Still four decades after his death, hymns to his
praise were sung by Christians and Jews united in
their adherence to Mendelssohn's ideas. Lessing
raised a poetic monument to his friend by using him
as a model for the hero of his drama Nathan The
Wise.
Managing a silk firm and forced by Christian
controversialists into extended defenses of his
loyalty to Judaism, Mendelssohn lost his health,
but campaigned heroically against the civil
disabilities imposed on Jews, especially the
invidious requirements regarding oaths. He died in
1786. He was the grandfather of the famous composer
Felix Mendelssohn.
In The Radical
Academy
Enrich
Your Life With a Philosophy Book...
Enrich
Your Life With a Philosophy
Magazine...
|