|
Certain
Forms of Virtue Lead to Sin
by Judah ben Samuel of
Regensburg
There is a kind of humility which inherits
Gehenna, and causes the heirs of the humble to
inherit a burning fire in Gehenna. In what manner
is it? If a man sees that his children, relatives,
or pupils are of bad behavior, and it lies within
his power to correct them, by reprimanding or by
beating them, but he says to himself: "I shall
rather be agreeable to them and not reprimand or
beat them," he causes them to inherit Gehenna. For
they will corrupt their way, and will even do
mischief to their father and their mother, so that
they will despise them, and curse the day wherein
they were born. It is in connection with such a
case that it is written: "He that spareth the rod
hateth his son." It is also said that he who smites
his grown-up son transgresses the injunction: "Put
not a stumbling-block before the blind." But a son
that is accustomed to reproofs of instruction, and
is beaten while small, will not resent if his
father beats him when he is grown up. It is also
written: "Unless I had believed to see the goodness
of the Lord"; there are some dots on the word
Unless, for David said: "Peradventure I
caused my sons to sin, and am not able to make
amends by repenting"; for it is written: "And his
father had not grieved him all his life in saying:
"And his father had not grieved him all his life in
saying: 'Why hast thou done so?'"
There is another kind of humility which likewise
brings a man down to Gehenna. For instance, a man
sits in a court of justice, and knows that the
judges are in error; or a private man knows that
the court is in error, but says: "How shall I go
and put them to shame?" or a man knows that the
judges are not well-versed in law, while he is
well-versed, and when they say to him: "Sit with us
that we may not go astray," he replies: "I shall
not take a seat, for ye are well-versed." It is
obvious that if they go astray, the sin is to be
attached to him. Another instance is, when a man
hears that the congregation speak falsely, and he
says: "Who am I that I should speak before them?"
Behold, it is written: "And in thy majesty prosper,
ride on, in behalf of truth and humility of
righteousness"; from this we infer that there is a
kind of humility which is not righteousness, as the
above and similar cases show. It is also said: "An
untutored priest should not say the benedictions in
the presence of scholars."
There is a kind of charity which is pernicious.
In what manner is it? One who gives alms to
adulterers or to a glutton or a drunkard. For it is
written: "She shall not fall into harlotry," and
thou mayest read: "She shall not cause to fall into
harlotry"; "Thou shall not cause to commit
adultery." "Thou shalt not murder," and it may be
read: "Thou shalt not cause to murder." He who
supplies weapons of destruction to murderers is
regarded as if he himself had committed murder. For
it is written: "He hath also prepared for him the
weapons of death." He who gives food to robbers is
like their accomplice. Similarly, he who gives alms
to adulterers is regarded as though he had aided
them and brought them together, for they take the
money that is given to them, and offer it as hire
to harlots. It is also said that a man should give
no alms at all rather than give it publicly. In a
similar sense it is also said that if a man who
cannot pay his debts gives alms, it is obvious that
his charity is robbery.
There is a kind of piety which is bad. For
instance, a man whose hands are unclean sees a holy
book fall into the fire, and says: "It is better
that it should be burned," and does not touch the
book. Another instance had also been cited: a man
sees a woman drown in the river, and says: "It is
better that she should drown than that I should
touch her."
There is also false piety. For instance: a man
brings out a Scroll of the Law into the public
thoroughfare on the Sabbath on account of a fire;
or when a man says: "How shall I save a man's life
and profane the Sabbath?" Another instance is: a
question about declaring a thing forbidden or
unlawful is referred to a man who knows that he is
well-versed in the Law, though there are others
like him in the city, and he says: "Address the
question to others"; behold, his meekness may lead
to sin: peradventure if he had given his decision,
he would have forbidden that which others had
declared lawful.
There is sometimes a righteous judge that
perishes in his righteousness. For instance: he
sees two litigants, one being a swindler, and the
other a simpleton; the swindler knows how to plead,
but the simpleton, who does not know how to plead,
is right; concerning him it is written: "Open thy
mouth for the dumb." Likewise, if he knows that the
verdict is unjust, one of the litigants having
hired false witnesses, he should say: "Let the sin
be attached to the witnesses."
A favor sometimes turns out to be harmful, and
is regarded as an evil for its author and his
offspring. In what manner is it? For instance: a
man causes that sinners and they that led others
astray should dwell in the city. Now since it is
bad for the people of the city, it is evident that
he and his offspring will stumble over them, and
they will do mischief to his offspring. It is in
connection with such a case that it is written:
"And he did that which is not good among his
people." (Another explanation: And he did that
which is not good among his people refers to
him who disgraces his family; he is punished,
because he sinned by inflicting shame and injury
upon his people). Another instance: he who does a
good deed in order to be honored and to praise
himself thereby.
Excerpted from Sefer
Hasidim, in Post-Biblical Hebrew
Literature; Jewish Publication Socety of
America.
|
A
History of Jewish
Philosophy
in
the Middle Ages,
by
Colette Sirat
The
Cambridge Companion
to
Medieval
Jewish Philosophy,
by
Daniel H. Frank
|