|
THE
CRITICAL REVISION OF POSITIVISM
Recent philosophical thought, for our purposes
here, extends from the end of the nineteenth
century to the present day and is generally
characterized by four major movements:
- The first is a critical revision of
Positivism;
- The second undertakes to construct a new
metaphysics which, in so far as it is opposed to
materialistic Positivism, is called
"spiritualistic";
- The third is a young movement which springs
from the writings of novelist Ayn Rand and is
called Objectivism;
- The fourth is the phenomenal growth of
interest in commonsense philosophical reason as
expressed in the Perennial Philosophy, including
Modern Aristotelianism, Neo-Thomism,
Neo-Scholasticism, and Contextual Realism.
I.
GERMAN PSYCHOLOGISM
Wilhelm
Wundt
(1832-1920)
One of the most notable opponents of Positivism
was the German Wilhelm Wundt, considered to be one
of the founders of modern experimental psychology.
In his ten-volume work, Social Psychology,
Wundt investigates the collective and social soul,
producer of determined values such as language,
custom, myth, etc. Wundt's most representative
philosophical works are: Introduction to
Psychology; System of Philosophy; and
his Logic and Ethic.
For Wundt, philosophy has one determined
function: to systematize the results or findings of
the various sciences in a single over-all picture
of the world and life. Life the Positivists, Wundt
begins with immediate experience, which is,
according to him, the undifferentiated unity of
subject and object, of representative and volitive
elements.
Reflection works upon this immediate datum, this
undifferentiated reality, and draws from it
distinctions and abstractions. Thus, through
reflection, a distinction is made between subject
and object; between content (sensations) and form
(space and time). So, also, abstractions result in
individual empirical concepts; in general concepts,
which form science; and in the most general
concepts, which are the basis of philosophy (world,
soul, God). These last arise from the need in which
man finds himself to go beyond the limits of
space.
Wundt considers the soul not as a substance but
as an activity forever creating new syntheses.
However, the soul is not reducible to the elements
which enter into the composition of the syntheses,
as mechanical Positivism would have it. For Wundt,
all reality is activity. The ego performs its
activity in so far as it finds an obstacle in
another ego. Representation (knowledge) is nothing
more than a mode of this interaction of the egos.
All the particular activities of individual egos
are nothing other than fragments of the Universal
Will which, through this fragmentation of itself,
objectivates itself in the history of the human
race and its various peoples. Particular wills
voluntarily or involuntarily bow before the
Universal Will, and thus the universal plan
intended by the Universal Will is realized.
Wundt's metaphysics is simply an enlargement of
his psychology. Being is conceived on the basis of
the soul's activity. God is considered immanent in
reality, that is, pantheistically and
atheistically.
In The Radical
Academy
The positive
contributions of Wilhelm Wundt to the Perennial
Philosophy: None
II.
THE NEW POSITIVISM
Ernst
Mach
(1838-1916)
Ernst Mach (picture)
was professor of physics at the University of
Prague, and later professor of philosophy in
Vienna. In his Analysis of Sensations
(1886), Mach defines physics and psychology in
common terms and shows that scientific method is
equally applicable to both. On this basis Mach
offers a theory of knowledge based on the
phenomenalism of Hume and the positivists. The
world consists solely of sensations, the the
"thing-in-itself" is an illusion.
The aim of science is the discovery of facts.
Other problems relating to the thing-in-itself are
not the concern of science. Knowledge is built on
pure experience through sensations. Metaphysics is
opposed and voluntarism favored. Hence, knowledge
is an instrument of the will, the result of the
needs of practical life (pragmatism). Thoughts
illuminate the will. Thoughts and observations are
in agreement and express themselves in adaptation
and selection.
Mach resolves that body and mind are reducible
into common elements. Physical things, in their
knowable aspects, are reducible to the sum of their
sensible properties (Hume, Mill, and the
sensationalistic school). The physical object is a
duplicate of sensible appearances. The physical
object is identified with its sensible appearances.
The physical and the mental are but different
systems of homogeneous elements. An element's
dependence on other elements is correlated with
changes observed or experimentally induced in other
elements.
Science is therefore concerned with "functional
relations" by which the elements of experience are
controlled. The purpose of science is to "save
experiences" by achieving ideas in which they are
summarized and anticipated. How far the functional
relations which appear as concepts in the finished
product of knowledge are confined to the elements
themselves, and how far they are creations of
science, is not clear.
In The Radical
Academy
Elsewhere On the
Internet
III.
CRITICAL POSITIVISM
Harald
Höffding
(1843-1931)
After a long, difficult struggle, Harald
Höffding resolved to renounce theology and to
devote his life to philosophy. It was his great
esteem for Kierkegaard, the adversary of the
established church and inquirer into the mystery of
personal faith, that fortified Höffding in his
decision. He became Denmark's most important modern
philosopher, and his works have also been read and
highly appreciated in France, England and
Germany.
Höffding was more interested in
philosophical problems than in systems. Asked which
philosopher was his personal ideal, Höffding
answered Spinoza. But he rejected Spinoza's system.
He only loved and revered his personality.
Höffding called hi,self a critical positivist.
He held that experience is of decisive importance
to all a philosopher might think, but declared that
experience is a problem that defies the efforts of
all philosophers. To Höffding, philosophy
alone frees human mind from habits, prejudices and
traditions. It enlarges the spiritual horizon in
such a manner as no special science can.
In The Radical
Academy
Elsewhere On The
Internet
The positive
contributions of Ernst Mach to the Perennial
Philosophy: None
Also see: American
Pragmatism in the American Philosophy
section.
Enrich
Your Life With a Philosophy
Book...
|