|
The Four
Sources of Pleasure and Pain
by Jeremy Bentham
The happiness of the individuals, of whom a
community is composed, that is their pleasures and
their security, is the end and the sole end which
the legislator ought to have in view: the sole
standard, in conformity to which each individual
ought, as far as depends upon the legislator, to be
made to fashion his behaviour. But whether
it be this or any thing else that is to be
done, there is nothing by which a man can
ultimately be made to do it, but either pain
or pleasure. Having taken a general view of these
two grand objects (viz. pleasure, and what
comes to the same thing, immunity from pain) in the
character of final causes; it will be
necessary to take a view of pleasure and pain
itself, in the character of efficient causes or
means.
There are four distinguishable sources from
which pleasure and pain are in use to flow:
considered separately, they may be termed the
physical, the political, the
moral, and the religious: and
inasmuch as the pleasures and pains belonging to
each of them are capable of giving a binding force
to any law or rule of conduct, they may all of them
be termed sanctions.
If it be in the present life, and from the
ordinary course of nature, not purposely modified
by the interposition of the will of any human
being, nor by any extraordinary interposition of
any superior invisible being, that the pleasure or
the pain takes place or is expected, it may be said
to issue from or to belong to the physical
sanction.
If at the hands of a particular person or
set of persons in the community, who under names
correspondent to that of judge, are chosen
for the particular purpose of dispensing it,
according to the will of the sovereign or supreme
ruling power in the state, it may be said to issue
from the political sanction.
If at the hands of such chance persons in the
community, as the party in question may happen in
the course of his life to have concerns with,
according to each man's spontaneous disposition,
and not according to any settled or concerted rule,
it may be said to issue from the moral or
popular sanction.
If from the immediate hand of a superior
invisible being, either in the present life, or in
a future, it may be said to issue from the
religious sanction.
Pleasures or pains which may be expected to
issue from the physical, political, or
moral sanctions, must all of them be
experienced, if ever, in the present life:
those which may be expected to issue from the
religious sanction, may be expected to be
experienced either in the present life or in a
future.
...
Of these four sanctions the physical is
altogether, we may observe, the ground-work of the
political and the moral: so is it also of the
religious, in as far as the latter bears relation
to the present life. It is included in each of
those other three. This may operate in any case,
(that is, any of the pains or pleasures belonging
to it may operate) independently of them:
none of them can operate but by means of
this. In a word, the powers of nature may operate
of themselves; but neither the magistrate, nor men
at large, can operate, nor is God in the case in
question supposed to operate, but through
the powers of nature.
|
The
Principles of Morals and
Legislation,
by
Jeremy Bentham
|