|
An Art
Peculiar to Man
by William Ernest Hocking
Using the word art in the widest sense, as
including all conscious efforts to remake the
world, we may say that all animal behavior includes
some degree of outwardly directed art. While life
permits its world to shape it, it promotes thereby
the artisanship by which it shapes the world.
There is but on exception, presumably, to the
rule that the arts of animals are directed to the
environment. The human being does deliberately
undertake, while reshaping his outer world, to
reshape himself also. In meeting unsatisfactory
conditions, -- scarcity of good, danger, etc., --
the simpler animal does what it can to change those
conditions. The human being does likewise; but
there sometimes occurs to him the additional
reflection, "perhaps there should be some change in
myself also." Scarcity of good may become to him an
argument for greater foresight or industry, danger
for more caution. If a beast is threatened, it may
either fight or retreat: if a man is threatened, he
may (while dealing with the facts) become a critic
also of his own fear or anger.
Man thus becomes for himself an object of artful
reconstruction, and this is an art peculiar to man.
Whatever is done in the world by way of producing
better human individuals, whether for the benefit
of the species or for the ends of individuals
themselves, man is an agent in it: it is done not
merely to him but by him. He has become judge of
his own nature and its possibilities. "Evolution"
leaves its work in his hands -- so far as he is
concerned.
I do not say that man is the only creature that
has a part in its own making. Every organism may be
said (with due interpretation of terms) to build
itself, to regenerate itself when injured, to
recreate itself and, in striving for its numerous
ends, to develop itself -- to grow. It may be, as
we were saying, an agent in evolution. But in all
likelihood, it is only the human being that does
these things with conscious intention, that
examines and revises his mental as well as his
physical self, and that proceeds according to a
preformed idea of what this self should be. To be
human is to be self-conscious; and to be
self-conscious is to bring one's self into the
sphere of art, as an object to be judged, altered,
improved.
Human beings as we find them are accordingly
artificial products; and for better or for worse
they must always be such. Nature has made us:
social action and our own efforts must continually
remake us. Any attempt to reject art for "nature"
can only result in an artificial naturalness which
is far less genuine and less pleasing than the
natural work of art.
Excerpted from Human Nature
and Its Remaking, by William Ernest
Hocking
|
What
man can make of man, by William Ernest
Hocking
Human
nature and its remaking, by William Ernest
Hocking
|