|
June 6, 2006
What
Should I Consider When Buying a New
Television?
by Gary North, Ph.D.
Modern
man is addicted to entertainment. It is costing him
a fortune. If he were to invest his time spent on
entertainment, and compound its output at 10% per
annum, it would be a fortune at age 65.
There are few modern inventions most expensive
than "free" TV. Your time is not free. Besides,
free TV is aimed at a low common denominator,
culturally speaking. Advertisers are buying the
18-49 age group. They are not buying IQ points.
If you prefer visual entertainment at home as
your main means of recreation, then you should pay
more for the equipment. Then limit the time spent
in front of your home theater. Make this time
special.
Compared to the value of your time, the cost of
the equipment is minimal.
Before making any decision, do some homework on
the latest deals and gadgets. Here is the strategy
I use:
http://snipurl.com/gadgetdeals
Television Technology
I have been looking at what is going on in
television these days. It's really confusing. It's
easy to spend a lot of money and not get what
you're really after. So, here a few
considerations.
The #1 consideration is that a law goes into
effect on July 1. All new TV sets that are 25" or
larger must have a built-in high-definition tuner.
Sets on display today are about to become
superseded. Next month's models will offer more
features. They may even be cheaper. If not cheaper,
then at least the models on display this month are
likely to be marked down, especially those that are
"HD ready," meaning without a $200 HD tuner.
Next, the death of today's analog TV is now set
by law: February, 2009. All local TV stations will
then broadcast signals only digitally. Digital
broadcasting takes far less frequency spectrum than
analog signals. Digital TV requires a box or
built-in tuner that will decode the signals.
Digital TV is universally available today. These
images do not contain snow or create ghost images.
But they are all or nothing. Either your set
receives them clearly or not at all.
Digital does not mean high definition. It is
merely a way to broadcast TV signals through the
air. Local TV stations broadcast analog signals
(most viewers) and digital signals (advanced
viewers). They may not broadcast high definition
digital signals, especially during non-prime
time.
Most cable and satellite programming is not in
high definition. Local over-the-air network TV is
often HD, but not the broadcasts of these same
programs on cable. You have to pay premium cable
prices to get a handful of HDTV channels.
So, to maximize your HDTV viewing, you must
watch over-the-air network channels. Ironically,
this means that the best reception requires a
rooftop antenna. Remember the 1950s and 1960s, with
those hideous rooftop antennas? They may not be
coming back, but for HDTV buffs, that's the best
way today.
I use an indoor antenna, the Terk TV5. It works
marginally better than rabbit ears, which are no
better today than in 1949. I speak from experience.
I remember 1949 rabbit ears.
To find which local TV networks broadcast HDTV
in your area, and where to aim one of those
rotor-controlled outdoor antennas, click here:
http://antennaweb.org
Then there is your DVD player. It's not high
definition unless it's one of the new $1,000-plus
units offered in rival formats, HD and Blue-Ray. We
are about to see a replay of the VHS vs. Betamax
war of the early 1980s. The winner will take all --
eventually.
A standard DVD player produces what is known as
ED (enhanced definition) broadcast quality. This is
referred to as 480p, or 480 lines per inch,
progressive scan. Because standard TVs are also 480
lines per inch of active video "information," this
may not seem to be a major improvement, but it is.
Clarity is dramatically improved, especially for
larger screens.
There are very few DVD movies that are formatted
for true HDTV, which means 1080 lines per inch.
Most HDTV sets are 1080i (interlaced), which isn't
as good as 1080p. Most HDTVs offer 720p, which is
better (less jerky) for high-motion broadcasts such
as sports than 1080i.
Top-quality sets offer two million pixels. This
means 1,920 x 1080 pixels. Another factor to look
at is the contrast ratio: higher is better.
Anything over 1,000 is very good.
When you view a set, watch especially for black.
The blacker the blacks, the better. Sony sets are
noted for their deep black images on the LCD
screens. The CRT screens have no problem with
black.
Types of TV Sets
Here, things get tricky. You have to trade off
features and benefits.
For clarity, the best sets are the old-fashioned
tube sets, meaning cathode ray tubes or CRTs. They
are by far the cheapest sets, too. Expect to pay
$600 to $750 for a 32-inch screen (diagonally
measured). There are two disadvantages: (1) they
extend to the rear, and the larger the screen, the
more they extend; (2) they are heavy. Some sets are
120 lbs. Others are 200 lbs. In short, they are
monsters. Take your tape measure to the TV store.
Pay extra money to have it delivered and
installed.
For convenience, the LCD sets are best. They are
basically large, flat-panel computer screens. They
weigh 20 lbs or less. They are not subject to
permanent color distortion from unshielded
speakers, which are magnetic. CRT sets are. Their
colors do not fade after a few years, as plasma
screens do. Expect to pay $1,500 to $3,000.
For maximum viewing size, plasma screens and
rear-projection screens are mandatory. Plasma
screens are flat-panel. Hang them on a wall. They
are large: 50" to 60" or larger. Defect: Their
colors fade. They are expensive: $3,000 to $10,000.
Pay for repair insurance.
The rear-projection units are large. For their
screen size, they are much cheaper per square inch
than plasma units: $2,000 to $3,000. Their defect
is that they are highly directional. You must sit
right in front of them for maximum viewing
pleasure.
Then there is screen shape. For wide-screen DVDs
and movies, the 9:16 ratio is best.
http://snipurl.com/tv16x9
It displays traditional TV broadcasts by
inserting black borders, right and left.
For traditional TV broadcasts, the 4:3 ratio is
best.
http://snipurl.com/tv4x3
To display wide-screen movies, the 4x3 set
inserts black borders, top and bottom. I recommend
9x16. I don't watch much TV. I do watch movies.
Sound
Adding an external stereo system to your TV is
like going to EDTV: a quantum leap. Going to Dolby
7.1 (with subwoofer) is like going to HDTV. It's a
noticeable improvement, but marginal compared to
the first jump.
Now, for the bad news. I mean really, truly, "it
isn't fair" news. The key component is your ears.
Age is the deciding factor in sound quality,
especially for men.
"How bad is it?" you ask. Really bad. Look at
this pair of charts of what happens to you after
age 25.
http://snipurl.com/badears
I remember at age 14, half a century ago, paying
close attention to speaker systems that would
deliver 50 to 18,000 cycles per second (later
re-named hertz). I wanted those high frequencies,
which is where high fidelity (an ancient phrase)
really shines. Today, it's money down the drain for
me. This conforms to North's law of aging:
"Whenever you can easily afford it, you can't
use it any more."
It is often said of a man's memory, "It's the
second thing to go." Wrong. It's the third.
You can spend $20,000 or more on a home theater
system. This makes no sense to me. If you buy a 32"
CRT unit for (say) $600 -- plus delivery! -- and a
receiver-amplifier that offers Dolby 7.1 and THX
sound for $375, and six speakers plus a low
frequency subwoofer for a total of $700 to $1,200,
you will have a very good system. I like Boston
Acoustic speakers, but speakers are very personal.
Besides, I am less and less able to tell the
difference.
For overall effect, you could spend half of what
I recommend on the sound system and still have an
impressive home theater. Your ears and the
acoustics of the TV room will probably have a
greater effect than doubling or halving my
recommended expenditure on a sound system.
Use the Pioneer VSX-1014TX as a starting point
for the multi-channel amplifier system. The
producers of these units are highly competitive.
New models keep doing more. The main defect of the
Pioneer is its lack of an easy alligator clip
system for hooking up speaker wires. Messing around
with wires is a pain.
By the way, don't pay extra for fancy wiring.
Good, old-fashioned, rubber-coated copper wire,
sold at Lowe's by the foot, is fine. Use 16 gauge
for small rooms, 14 for larger. For details, click
here:
http://snipurl.com/wiregauge
Home Video to DVD Production
If you want to transfer your home videos to DVD,
and you know how to do this with your existing
computer, you don't need a separate system. But if
you are not ready to do this on your computer, you
can buy a separate VHS/DVD recorder. Make sure it
has a hard drive. You can also record shows and
movies off the cable or satellite TV systems.
One product that does this is the Panasonic
DMR-EH75VS unit. It sells for around $450. Use this
as an initial features guide for comparing
comparable products.
Conclusion
"Mr. Tweedy" is a true middle-class cartoon
character, a comfortable loser. I remember a
cartoon that showed his closet. It was stacked to
the top with videotapes of "Bowling for
Dollars."
Budget your time well. It is your only
non-renewable resource. There is no such thing as
free time.
Dr.
Gary North earned a Ph.D. in history and is one of
America's keenest economic analysts and
commentators. He supports the Austrian school of
economics and is a previous assistant to
libertarian congressman Dr. Ron Paul. Visit his
website at http://garynorth.com.
To
subscribe to Gary North's Reality Check go to
http://www.dailyreckoning.com/sub/GetReality.cfm
If
you enjoyed this essay and would like to read more
of Gary's writing please visit his website at
http://www.garynorth.com
or http://www.freebooks.com
Because
The Radical Academy publishes essays and articles
on its website does not imply acceptance or
approval of the comments or opinions expressed by
the author of the material. Nor is the Academy
responsible for any misrepresentation of the facts
included. It is your job to be a critical
reader.
Enrich
Your Life With A Business Or Finance
Book
Enrich
Your Life With A Business Or Finance
Magazine
|