|
The
Question of Free Will - Volition
Volition - An
Outline-Summary
Besides sense-perception, sensuous appetency,
and intellection, we all experience a phenomena
called volition, the activity of the will, as a
phase of our mental life.
A. The
Concept of the Will
Our everyday life manifests many attitudes and
acts which reveal the activity of the will. The
will is conceived and defined as rational appetency
or the power to strive for an intellectually
perceived good and to shun an intellectually
perceived evil.
B. The Object
of the Will
We strive for material and spiritual things
which seem good to us. From the individual things
where are good the intellect abstracts the
universal concept of the "good in general."
"Goodness" is the suitability of a thing to a
natural tendency or appetency.
The adequate object of the human will is
everything that is good.
The formal object of the human will is the good
as good, provided it be suitable to the willing
subject. Whatever is an object of the will, is
striven for under the aspect of a "good."
C. Types of
the Good
We distinguish between the ontological, the
physical, and the moral good; between the absolute
and the relative good; between the objective and
the subjective good; between the real and the
apparent good; between the disinterested, the
delectable, and the useful good. Every good is a
"value," recognized and appreciated as something
perfect or perfective.
Definitions:
Ontological good: when a thing is a good
in its very entity or reality. Every being, since
it possesses a certain amount of entity or reality,
is an ontological good, because its entity or
reality is suitable for the tendency of its own
nature to be what it is and to perfect itself and
to retain its perfection.
Physical good: when a thing satisfies the
demand of the nature of a being. Each being has its
own specific and individual nature, and as such it
has a very definite end and purpose. For us, for
instance, as human beings, sight, hearing,
well-functioning of our physical organs, are
physical goods.
Moral good: when a thing has everything
demanded of it by the moral law. An action, for
example, may be physically perfect, but it may
contravene the moral law; in that case, it would be
physically good but morally evil.
Absolute good: anything suitable to a
being itself, irrespective of other beings. Any
reality which a being possesses, whether
substantial or accidental, is an absolute good for
that being. For us, for instance, all bodily
structures, organs, powers, and functions are
absolute goods.
Relative good: anything which is suitable
to another being; food, drink, clothes, shelter,
and so forth, are relative goods for us.
Objective good: anything that is good in
itself. Any absolute or relative good is an
objective good in this sense.
Subjective good: the actual possession of
an objective good. An artistic painting, for
example, is an objective good in itself; it becomes
a subjective good for me, if I acquire it as my
own.
Real good: a good that is judged to be
good for a being, and it actually is good for that
particular being. The nature, bodily limbs, senses,
intellect, will, and so forth, are real goods for
us as human beings.
Apparent good: a good that is judged to
be good for a being, but it is actually not good
for it. For example, a certain kind of food may
seem a real good for a critically ill patient, but
it may be very harmful; under the circumstances it
is an apparent good, even though it is something
which, in itself and for itself, is ontologically
good.
Disinterested good: any good considered
merely as giving perfection, irrespectively of any
pleasure derived though its acquisition or from its
possession. Health, knowledge, and virtue are such
goods.
Delectable good: a relative good which
gives pleasure or enjoyment. Food, drink,
companionship, sex, belong to this class of
goods.
Useful good: a relative good which
desired as a means to acquire perfection or
pleasure. There is always an ulterior end in view
when a good of this kind is desired. A game of
golf, for example, is a useful good, desired as a
means to promote one's health, to gain fame, to
obtain the pleasure of companionship, and so
forth.
D. Evil and
the Will
Evil is the privation of a required good. By the
fact that the will is necessitated by its very
nature to strive for the good it is also
necessitated to shun evil. When people desire
things that are physically harmful or morally evil,
they do so because they consider such things to be
a "good" for them.
E. Motive and
Motivation
A motive is an appreciated value realizable
through an act of volition. A double factor is
involved in a motive: the objective factor of the
goodness of the object of experience; and the
subjective factor of the intellectual knowledge of
this goodness on the part of the willing
subject.
Motives may be of a physical, intellectual, or
moral character; there are also inner and outer
motives.
By motivation is meant the arousal of the will
from a state of inaction into a state of action.
Motives reside in the intellect; the intellect
makes the practical judgment that this or that
thing is desirable and thereby elicits the act of
the will.
F. Natural
and Deliberate Volition
Since the good is the formal object of the will,
and since happiness is the fullness of good, the
will, by its very nature, must strive for
happiness; this kind of striving is natural
volition. Volition is said to be deliberate when,
after a consideration of the respective merits of
particular values, a preferential choice is
made.
G. Voluntary
Control
By voluntary control we understand the control
which the will exercises over the powers and
actions of the human organism. Experience proves
that we exercise voluntary control, though this
control is neither universal nor uniform. We have
no control over the functions of the cells. The
functions of the vegetative organs and of the
external senses are subject to indirect control. We
have direct control in some measure over bodily
movements, over the activities of the internal
senses, and over the intellect.
Voluntary movements have a tendency to become
gradually "mechanized." Some kinetic units are
hereditary; most of them, however, are acquired by
direct volition through repetition of acts.
Movements may be actually, virtually, or habitually
voluntary. Determining tendencies resemble virtual
or habitual voluntary actions.
H. The
Existence of Volition
That volition, as a distinct type of mental
experience, actually exists, is proved from the
facts of attention, from resolving on a task, from
reaction-time experiments, from the control of
emotions, from the inhibition of impulses and
desires, and from readjustments of the mode of
life.
Experiments on volition reveal the Ego-in-action
in every deliberate decision as the originator of
the act of willing, so that the active
interposition of the Ego manifests the act of the
will as an experience distinct from all other
conscious processes. The act of willing, therefore,
demands, a specific power, the will.
|