The Jonathan Dolhenty Archive The Radical Academy Main Menu Online Newsletter Academy Updates The M.J. Adler Archive The Dolhenty Archive Adventures in Philosophy Classic Philosophers Philosophical Critiques Philosophy Glossary Philosophy Quotations Philosophy Mini-Courses Thomas Aquinas Introductory Essays Philosophy Resources Politics Resources Religion Resources Education Resources Science Resources The Media Center Better Living Resource Center Business & Finance Resources Search Central Academy Bookstore Academy NewsStand Academy Emporium About the Academy Academy FAQs Ask the Academy Guestbook Academy Forum Calendar of Events Subscribe to Ezine Give Us Feedback Tell A Friend About Us Votecaster Cartoons & Comics Academy Chatroom
Formal Logic Select an Archive Category... Fundamentals Metaphysics Epistemology Logic/Statistics Ethics/Morality Current Affairs Main Page & Index
Academy Resources Glossary of Philosophical Terms Timeline of Philosophy A Timeline of American Philosophy Diagram: Development of Philosophic Thought Diagram: Divisions of Philosophy The Philosophy Resource Center The Religion Resource Center Books about Philosophy in The Radical Academy Bookstore Books about Religion in The Radical Academy Bookstore Click Here for New & Used College Textbooks at Discount Prices Click Here for College Education Information & Study Resources Shop Amazon Stores in the Radical Academy Bookstore Magazine Outlet Music Store Classical Music Store Video Store DVD Store Computer Store Camera & Photo Store Computer/Video Games Software Store Musical Instruments Outlet Store Cellular Phones Toys & Games Tools & Hardware Automotive Store Outdoor Living Consumer Electronics Home & Garden Kitchen & Housewares Baby Superstore Apparel & Accessories Gourmet Food Grocery Store Sporting Goods Jewelry & Watches Health & Personal Care Beauty Store Academy Showcase Specials		DEDUCTION: Part 3 - Page a Figures and Moods of The Categorical Syllogism by Jonathan Dolhenty, Ph.D.   The Third Figure   M P M S S P The middle term (M) is the subject of both premises. The rule for the Third Figure is: The minor premise must be affirmative and the conclusion must be particular. Explanation of the Rule First Part: The minor premise must be affirmative. If the minor premise is negative, the major premise would have to be affirmative. This is because the premises cannot consist of two negative propositions, according to General Rule Number 6. In that case, however, the major term (P), which is the predicate of the major premise, would be a particular term, since it is the predicate of an affirmative proposition. According to General Rule Number 7, a negative minor premise would necessitate a negative conclusion. That would make its predicate, which is the major term (P), a universal term. This would result in an illicit major, a violation of General Rule Number 2. This will occur every time the minor premise is negative. So the minor premise can never be negative and to avoid an illicit major, the minor premise must be affirmative. Second Part: The conclusion must be particular. The minor term (S) will always be a particular term in the premise since, according to the first part of this rule, the minor premise must be affirmative. In this minor premise the minor term (S) is the predicate. The predicate of an affirmative sentence is always particular. The minor term (S) is the subject of the conclusion. It must also be a particular term in the conclusion. Otherwise General Rule Number 2 would be violated and we would have an illicit minor. Therefore, the conclusion must be particular. The Valid Moods of the Third Figure When we consider the moods which are valid for the syllogisms of the Third Figure, we find that six of the eight possible legitimate combinations are valid and two are invalid. Here are the diagrams: Moods of the Third Figure A uM + pP A uM + pS pS + pP Valid A uM + pP E uM - uS uS - uP Illicit Major A uM + pP I pS + pS pS + pP Valid A uM + pP O pM - uS uS - uP Illicit Major E uM - uP A uM + pS pS - uP Valid E uM - uP I pM + pS pS - uP Valid I pM + pP A uM + pS pS + pP Valid O pM - uP A uM + pS pS - uP Valid Clearly, there are six valid moods for the Third Figure: A A, A I, E A, E I, I A, and O A. Each one follows the rule that the minor premise must be affirmative and the conclusion must be particular. The A E and A O moods are invalid because of an illicit major brought into the conclusion. They violate the first part of the rule: The minor premise must be affirmative. Study the following arguments which illustrate the valid moods: A All birds have wings. A All birds are bipeds. Therefore, Some bipeds have wings. A All geniuses think they are wise. I Some geniuses are foolish people. Therefore, Some foolish people think they are wise. E No misers are generous. A All misers are people who abuse their riches. Therefore, Some people who abuse their riches are not generous. E No animals are immortal. I Some animals are dogs. Therefore, Some dogs are not immortal. I Some Communists are revolutionary. A All Communists are radicals. Therefore, Some radicals are revolutionary. O Some criminals are teenagers. A All criminals break the law. Therefore, Some who break the law are teenagers. To Page 2-b of Figures and Moods of the Syllogism Enrich Your Life With a Philosophy Book... Enrich Your Life With a Philosophy Magazine... Main Page & Index
-- Top of Page -- [Homepage] [Newsletter] [Search] [Support the Academy] [Link to Us] [Contact the Academy] [Citing Articles from Our Website] [Privacy Policy & Disclaimer] Copyright 1998-99, 2000-01, & 2002-03 by The Radical Academy. All Rights Reserved.