|
Index for this
page...
All The Following Items Were Posted On July 1,
2007
FROM
THE MORTIMER ADLER FILE
Change: The word "change" is a synonym
for the word "becoming" and an antonym for the word
"being."
Things that come into being and pass away have a
permanent being while they are subject to all forms
of accidental change, such as change of place,
change of quality, and change in quantity. For
example, the apple that reddens on the sunlit tree
is, from moment to moment, the same apple,
otherwise it could not be said to be an identical
object undergoing change in color or size.
This leads to the distinction between
substantial and accidental change. The birth and
death of animal organisms is substantial change;
their motions from place to place, their changes in
quality and quantity, are accidental changes.
That which changes substantially in coming to be
and passing away does not change from being to
nonbeing. Substantial change is rather an
alteration in mode of being, a kind of
transformation, as when a living organism becomes a
decaying corpse. In the physical cosmos nothing
passes away absolutely; nothing violates the laws
of conservation.
When it is said that God creates ex
nihilo, nothing or absolute nonbeing is the
antecedent of the created cosmos. But when animal
organisms procreate offspring, they are generated
from preexistent seeds.
The importance of this point is that if the
cosmos were ever to cease to be, the consequence of
this change would be nothingness or absolute
nonbeing. That radical change is not a
transformation of being, as the decaying corpse is.
It is being's negation or denial.
From Adler's
Philosophical Dictionary: 125 Key Terms for the
Philosopher's Lexicon. Have you a copy of
this book in your personal library? If not,
consider getting one. Read Max Weismann's review of
this book by Clicking
Here.
THE
PHILOSOPHERS SPEAK
Ludwig
Wittgenstein (1889-1951)
"Wittgenstein is known (1) for being the founder
of two philosophic movements, one dedicated to the
analysis of an ideal logical language, the other
aiming to clarify thought through analysis of
ordinary language; (2) for his conviction that
analysis is the only proper role of philosophy; (3)
for his belief that all philosophical problems can
be either solved or dissolved; (4) for the 'picture
theory' of language; (5) for his conclusion that
meaning is determined by context." -- Professor
James L. Christian. Read about Ludwig
Wittgenstein in The Radical Academy.
- Don't ask for the meaning, ask for the
use.
-
- For an answer which cannot be expressed the
question too cannot be expressed.
-
- The object of philosophy is the logical
clarification of thought.
-
- Philosophy is not a theory but an
activity.
-
- Philosophy limits the thinkable and
therefore the unthinkable.
-
- Everything that can be thought of at all can
be thought of clearly. Everything that can be
said can be said clearly.
-
- The philosopher's treatment of a question is
like the treatment of an illness.
-
- The aspects of things that are most
important for us are hidden because of their
simplicity and familiarity ... we fail to be
struck by what, once seen, is most striking and
most powerful.
-
- One cannot guess how a word functions. One
has to look at its use and learn from
that.
-
- Philosophy may in no way interfere with the
actual use of language; it can in the end only
describe it. For it cannot give any foundation
either. It leaves everything as it is.
-
- Philosophy is a battle against the
bewitchment of our intelligence by means of
language.
-
- What is your aim in philosophy? To show the
fly the way out of the fly bottle.
-
- Every truly philosophical problem is a
problem of analysis; and in problems of analysis
the best method is that which sets out from
results and arrives at the premises.
Source: Volume 1I of The
Wisdom Seekers: Great Philosophers of the Western
World, by James L. Christian. If you want
an excellent and comprehensive history of
philosophy, the two volumes in this set are among
the best available. And I'm not just saying that
because Professor Christian is a personal friend. I
used his introductory textbook in philosophy --
Philosophy:
An Introduction to the Art of Wondering -- when
I was teaching an introduction to philosophy course
many years ago. It is an excellent introduction.
J.D.
FOR THE
RECORD
1.
Influential American Philosopher Richard Rorty Dead
At 75
"On June 8, 2007, American philosopher Richard
Rorty died at the age of 75. Rorty is now commonly
associated with one of the roster of scare words
used to get Americans to vote against their own
self-interests: He was (supposedly) that bicoastal
monster known as a "relativist." Take heart, Rorty
was also despised by the bien pensant left, who
found him a political quietist and, in matters of
taste, an airy-fairy Proustian snob. I knew Rorty
briefly, when I was a graduate student at the
University of Virginia, and to me he was never a
relativist, a quietist, or a snob. He was the
perfect embodiment of an American Enlightenment
founded by Mr. Jefferson. If such words are
restorable to their least debased senses, he was a
liberal and a democrat -- that is, a thinker who
wanted America to fulfill its charter, and devote
itself to maximum human flourishing." -- Stephen
Metcalf, on Slate.com.
Source: Richard
Rorty: What made him a crucial American
philosopher? - Slate.com
Resources:
2.
Ten Years After ACLU v. Reno, Free Speech Still
Needs Defending
Online free speech faces many threats today, but
the Internet's incredible abundance and variety of
expression might never have blossomed to begin with
if the first major court battle had gone the wrong
way.
This is the ten-year anniversary of the U.S.
Supreme Court's landmark decision in Reno v. ACLU,
which recognized that free speech on the Internet
merits the highest standards of Constitutional
protection. The Electronic Frontier Foundation
(EFF) participated as both plaintiff and co-counsel
in the case, which successfully challenged the
online censorship provisions of the Communications
Decency Act (CDA) of 1996. The Court's decision --
its first involving the Internet -- was issued on
June 26, 1997.
The CDA fight was one of the first big rallying
points for online freedom. When the law passed,
thousands of websites turned their backgrounds
black in protest. EFF launched its "blue ribbon"
campaign and millions of websites around the world
joined in support of free speech online. Even
today, you can find the blue ribbon throughout the
Web. [Ed. Note: The Radical Academy is a member
of the "blue ribbon" campaign.]
EFF Senior Counsel David Sobel, who served as
co-counsel in the case, notes: "The Reno decision
defined the First Amendment for the 21st century.
The Court wrote on a clean slate and established
the fundamental principles that govern free speech
issues in the electronic age."
EFF's work over the past ten years demonstrates
that while the technology might evolve, threats to
online expression persist and core First Amendment
principles must be vigilantly defended. The CDA was
a crystal clear case of unconstitutional government
censorship, and the challenges today are sometimes
more complex. EFF's efforts today include:
- Intermediaries: EFF fights to protect
Internet middlemen -- like hosting services,
search engines, and ISPs -- from overreaching
liability, so that creators of amazing free
speech tools don't have to worry about being
held responsible for everything that Internet
users say.
- "Fair Use": EFF defends "fair use" of
copyrighted material, including its ongoing
campaign to counter bogus copyright takedowns on
YouTube and elsewhere.
- Bloggers' Rights: EFF promotes bloggers'
rights through litigation and distribution of a
comprehensive legal guide.
- Anonymous speech: EFF supports online
anonymity, primarily through representation of
defendants in "John Doe" lawsuits filed by large
corporations and thin-skinned public officials
who want to intimidate their anonymous
critics.
- "Right to Know": EFF uses the Freedom of
Information Act to promote the public's "right
to know" and facilitate informed and open debate
on technology and civil liberties issues.
The fight against direct government censorship
of online speech continues, too. EFF continues to
participate in the pending litigation against the
Children's Online Protection Act (COPA), a slightly
narrower but still gravely dangerous version of the
CDA that the Supreme Court has twice enjoined.
While it can sometimes seem that there are more
fronts than ever in the fight for free speech
online, the battles we face today would be much,
much harder without that first victory in ACLU v.
Reno. With your help, we'll fight to make sure that
ten years from now, we can look back and see how
today's battles helped pave the way for an even
better future online.
Source: The
Electronic Frontier Foundation
Resources:
- For the Reno v. ACLU decision, Click
Here.
- For a news article on the "Turn the Web"
black protest Click
Here.
- For the Blue Ribbon campaign, Click
Here.
3.
The "Quiet Revolution" Against The Welfare
State
Millions of Americans are abandoning government
services in favor of private alternatives, in a
"quiet revolution" that may ultimately render the
welfare state obsolete.
That's the tantalizing argument made by Richard
Ebeling in his article "Ending the Welfare State
Through the Power of Private Action." Ebeling is
president of the Foundation for Economic Education
(FEE), America's first free-market think tank, and
his article appeared in the April issue of the
Foundation's fine magazine The Freeman.
"I believe that while many Americans find it
difficult to think politically "outside the box" of
Big Government, they have in fact lost confidence
in much of what government has promised or tried to
deliver," Ebeling says. "As this confidence has
been eroded, people have begun once more to take
care of themselves and their families."
Ebeling looks at three of the biggest, and
seemingly most entrenched, areas of today's federal
government:
Social Security:
- Over the last 20 years private retirement
planning has exploded. In 1985 there were 1,528
mutual funds offering investment opportunities
to private investors. By 2004, however, 8,044
mutual funds existed. Total mutual-fund assets
increased from $495 billion to 8.1 trillion. The
number of shareholder accounts went from 296,000
to over 267.4 million.
-
- This tells us the extent to which the
American people have implicitly declared that
they have no confidence in Social Security.
Education:
- [B]etween 1990 and 2004 attendance
at private schools (K-12) increased from 4.8
million to over 6.2 million, a 29 percent
increase. About 11.5 percent of all students in
the United States are now enrolled in more than
29,000 private schools; these schools represent
around 23 percent of all schools in the country.
A national survey in 2000 found that 48.6
percent of the schools were Catholic, 15.7
percent nonsectarian, 15 percent conservative
Christian, 6.1 percent Baptist, 4.3 percent
Lutheran, and 3.3 percent Jewish. Many of the
remaining private schools also were affiliated
with religious denominations. ...
-
- Plus, Today, well over one million children
may be homeschooled.
In all, Eberling says, about 12% of the U.S.
student population is being educated outside
government schools. That's an impressive number --
indeed, it is a revolution -- and it is growing
rapidly despite government taxes and
restrictions.
Health Care:
- Even while the Medicare and Medicaid rolls
are growing, a 'counterrevolution' against
government-provided health care is starting. A
handful of physicians have begun to opt out of
the system and all the paperwork and regulations
socialized medicine entails. They only accept
patients who are willing to pay out of their own
pockets, rather than with government dollars
taken from the taxpayers.
We might also note the dramatic growth of
lower-cost walk-in healthcare clinics at stores
like Wal-Mart, CVS, and Walgreen's. Such clinics
are expected to double in number this year alone to
700, and will continue to expand -- a market
response to government-created health care
failures.
Concludes Eberling: "In these three areas
individuals are taking back personal responsibility
from the government. They are not waiting for a
political movement to 'free' them. Instead, their
actions preceded and sparked the political debate
over whether government should monopolize these
services. Their cumulative effect has the potential
to transform society. ...
"By taking care of their own affairs, they are
delegitimizing the welfare state. Their actions
then influence the arena of ideas."
Source: Advocates
for Self-Government (James W. Harris)
Resources:
4.
Short Take
[Ed. Note: I have lived with house cats for
almost seventy years. I have always considered them
the most "philosophical" of our domestic animals
(you know -- independent, aloof, skeptical,
distrustful, argumentative, etc.). My current
companion, "Tigger" (13 years old this summer), is
stretched out on my desk as I write this wondering
when I will finish this darn E-Zine for some
quality "lap time." While this story has nothing to
do with philosophy or politics per se, I
found it interesting and wanted to share
it.]
"Some 10,000 years ago, somewhere in the Near
East, an audacious wildcat crept into one of the
crude villages of early human settlers, the first
to domesticate wheat and barley. There she felt
safe from her many predators in the region, such as
hyenas and larger cats.
"The rodents that infested the settlers' homes
and granaries were sufficient prey. Seeing that she
was earning her keep, the settlers tolerated her,
and their children greeted her kittens with
delight. At least five females of the wildcat
subspecies known as Felis silvestris lybica
accomplished this delicate transition from forest
to village.
"And from these five matriarchs all the world's
600 million house cats are descended. A scientific
basis for this scenario has been established by
Carlos A. Driscoll of the National Cancer Institute
and his colleagues. He spent more than six years
collecting species of wildcat in places as far
apart as Scotland, Israel, Namibia and Mongolia. He
then analyzed the DNA of the wildcats and of many
house cats and fancy cats."
To read the entire story see: Study
Traces Cat's Ancestry to Middle East
(Registration may be required)
5.
Quote Of The Month: On Freedom
"The only freedom which deserves the name, is
that of pursuing our own good in our own way, so
long as we do not attempt to deprive others of
theirs, or impede their efforts to obtain it." --
John Stuart Mill (1806-1873), English philosopher
and economist, who wrote On Liberty
(1859).
COUNSELING
CORNER: Helping those in the Old East understand
those in the Old West . . .
We who live in the western part of the United
States (the "Old West" as it's sometimes called),
are often misunderstood by our brother and sister
citizens in the eastern part of the country.
Sooooo...to help out our eastern brethren, we
provide a few common remarks with their appropriate
translation:
1. The engine's runnin' but ain't nobody
driving. Translation: Not
overly-intelligent.
2. Tighter than bark on a tree.
Translation: Not very generous.
3. Big hat, no cattle. Translation: All
talk and no action.
4. We've howdied, but we ain't shook yet.
Translation: We've made a brief
acquaintance, but not been formally introduced.
5. He thinks the sun come up just to hear him
crow. Translation: He has a pretty high
opinion of himself.
6. As welcome as a skunk at a lawn party.
Translation: (self-explanatory).
7. She's/He's got tongue enough for 10 rows of
teeth. Translation: Talks a lot.
8. It's so dry the trees are bribin' the dogs.
Translation: We really could use a little
rain around here.
9, Just because a chicken has wings don't mean
it can fly. Translation: Appearances can be
deceptive.
10. This ain't my first rodeo.
Translation: I've been around awhile.
11. He looks like the dog's been keepin' him
under the porch. Translation: Not the most
handsome of men.
12. They ate supper before they said grace.
Translation: Living in sin.
13. As full of wind as a corn-eating horse.
Translation: Rather prone to boasting.
14. You can put your boots in the oven, but that
don't make 'em biscuits. Translation: You
can say whatever you want about something, but that
doesn't change what it is.
A
LITTLE OF THIS & A LITTLE OF
THAT
A Little Wisdom: Numbers are like people;
torture them enough and they'll tell you
anything.
A Little Advice: Work is the greatest
thing in the world, so we should always save some
of it for tomorrow.
A Little Question: If a man says
something in the woods and there are no women
there, is he still wrong?
A Little Put-Down: Women who seek to be
equal to men lack ambition.
A Little Proverb: All good things in
moderation ..... including moderation.
A Little Reflection: There is no pleasure
in having nothing to do; the fun is in having lots
to do and not doing it.
A Little Definition: ADULT: A
person who has stopped growing at both ends and is
now growing in the middle.
A Little Quote: "To laugh often and much,
to win the respect of intelligent people and the
affection of children,to earn the appreciation of
honest critics and endure the betrayal of false
friends, to appreciate beauty, to find the best in
others, to leave the world a bit better, whether by
a healthy child, a garden patch, or a redeemed
social condition, to know even one life has
breathed easier because you have lived. This is to
have succeeded." -- Ralph Waldo Emerson
(1803-1882), American poet and essayist.
A Little Observation: "When women are
depressed they either eat or go shopping. Men
invade another country." -- Elayne Boosler.
A Little Quip: And on the 8th day God
said, OK Murphy, you take over.
ELSEWHERE
ON THE INTERNET
Some interesting & provocative articles
on other websites:
When
Totalitarianism Comes to America, It Will Come
Wrapped in a Whole-Grain, Low-Sodium,
Decaffeinated, Re-Usable, Non-Carbon-Footprint
Wrapper, by Karen De Coster: The Centers for
Disease Control and Prevention is sponsoring more
food totalitarianism for the purpose of suitably
herding the kiddies in their daily food round-ups
in public schools. An Institute of Medicine
committee -- set up at the behest of congress -- is
proposing strict standards for all foods available
in the government's daily internment camps.
They
call this a consensus?, by Lawrence Solomon:
"Only an insignificant fraction of scientists deny
the global warming crisis. The time for debate is
over. The science is settled." So said Al Gore ...
in 1992. Amazingly, he made his claims despite much
evidence of their falsity. A Gallup poll at the
time reported that 53% of scientists actively
involved in global climate research did not believe
global warming had occurred; . . .
Ron
Paul vs. the Throng - The Last of the Texas
Outsiders, by Alexander Cockburn: Put together
Murdoch's Fox News, a mid-May debate between
Republican presidential candidates and the state of
South Carolina and you have a hotbed of stupidity.
But to the fury of the Republican organizers there
was an intrusion of rational thought, in the person
of Ron Paul, a US congressman from Texas, classed
as a rank outsider in the nomination race.
What
if our mercenaries turn on us?, by Chris
Hedges: Armed units from the private security
firm Blackwater USA opened fire in Baghdad streets
twice in two days last week. It triggered a
standoff between the security contractors and Iraqi
forces, a reminder that the war in Iraq may be
remembered mostly in our history books for
empowering and building America's first modern
mercenary army.
Studies
Say Death Penalty Deters Crime: Anti-death
penalty forces have gained momentum in the past few
years, with a moratorium in Illinois, court
disputes over lethal injection in more than a
half-dozen states and progress toward outright
abolishment in New Jersey. ... What gets little
notice, however, is a series of academic studies
over the last half-dozen years that claim to settle
a once hotly debated argument -- whether the death
penalty acts as a deterrent to murder. The analyses
say yes.
Trashing
Teens: Psychologist Robert Epstein argues in a
provocative book, The Case Against
Adolescence, that teens are far more competent
than we assume, and most of their problems stem
from restrictions placed on them. Epstein spoke to
Psychology Today's Hara Estroff Marano about
the legal and emotional constraints on American
youth.
Insensitivity
Training: Facing the Crybaby Culture, by Mark P.
Shea: Every couple of days it seems somebody
falls apart due to "insensitivity." The problem has
been buzzing around in our headlines for years.
Danger
- boys having fun: A book of old-fashioned,
adventurous pastimes for lads and dads has become a
surprise bestseller. Christopher Middleton watched
his 11-year-old son transformed into a Middle Earth
warrior.
No
Guns, by Charley Reese: I'm ready at last to
support gun control. I believe every police agency
in the United States -- local, state and federal --
should be disarmed. After all, the gun-control
people have been saying for years that we private
citizens have no need for firearms. Well, if that's
true for us, it's true for the police.
Wanted
- Moral Education for Secular Children, by Paul
Kurtz: Secularism and humanism are among the
most powerful intellectual and ethical streams of
modern civilization. Their influence is felt all
across our planet. These streams have been growing
ever since the Renaissance:...
|