|
Index for this
page...
All The Following Items Were Posted On October
1, 2007
FROM
THE MORTIMER ADLER FILE
Dogmatism: Most people use the word
"dogmatism" in its dyslogistic sense. They forget
that the word "dogma" has a good meaning in
dogmatic theology, referring to the articles of
religious faith.
In philosophy, however, dogmatism is totally
inappropriate. Everything that is asserted or
denied must be submitted to rational inquiry that
seeks to establish it with certitude or
probability.
There are some philosophical positions the
affirmation of which are beyond the power of reason
to establish. An example is the main thesis of
ontological materialism, that nothing really exists
except bodies and their physical transformations.
That thesis, being a denial, therefore is a
negation, and as such it is indemonstrable.
Most of the contemporary scientists and
professors of philosophy who embrace materialism
unquestioningly do so without a logical qualm. They
mistakenly think that the evidence of their senses
tells them that all observable phenomena are
physical. Of course this is correct, but it does
not prove that only observable phenomena are real.
There is no evidence that reality does not and
cannot include the immaterial and the nonphysical.
To assert that is does not and cannot is sheer
dogmatism, of a kind that should be avoided in
philosophy.
Source: Adler's
Philosophical Dictionary: 125 Key Terms for the
Philosopher's Lexicon. Have you a copy of
this book in your personal library? If not,
consider getting one. Read Max Weismann's review of
this book by Clicking
Here.
THE
PHILOSOPHERS SPEAK
Epicurus
of Samos (c. 341 - 270 B.C.) Ancient Greek
philosopher
"Epicurus is remembered and eulogized (1) for
establishing the third institution of education in
Athens, known as 'The Garden'; (2) for dethroning
reason and placing human feelings at the center of
the philosophic life ('pleasure' is the alpha and
omega of a blessed life,' he said); (3) for
adapting Democritean physics to the pursuit of
happiness; (4) for teaching that ataraxia is
the ground-state of a happy life; (5) for his
(unfashionable) conviction that human nature is
good; (6) for discovering a correlation between
pleasure and health, pain and sickness; (7) for his
belief that there are but two ontological fears (of
death and of the gods) that disturb our lives; (8)
for making the epistemic distinction between
knowing subject and object known." -- Professor
James L. Christian. Read about Epicurus
in The Radical Academy.
- When it is time to go . . . we will have
life crying aloud in a glorious triumph-song
that we have lived well.
-
- The fool, with all his other faults, has
this also: he is always getting ready to
live.
-
- We must not spoil the enjoyment of the
blessings we have by pining for those we have
not.
-
- It is impossible to live pleasurably without
living wisely, well, and justly; and impossible
to live wisely, well, and justly without living
pleasurably.
-
- The truly free man is justified in having a
good laugh at all men.
-
- Vain is the word of that philosopher by
which no malady of mankind is healed.
-
- Human nature is not to be coerced but
persuaded.
-
- For just as there is no profit in medicine
unless it expels the diseases of the body, so
there is none in philosophy either unless it
expels the malady of the soul.
-
- The man at peace with himself is inoffensive
to his neighbor also.
-
- It is idle to seek from the gods what a man
is capable of providing for himself.
-
- Let nothing be done in your life which will
cause you fear if it becomes known to your
neighbor.
-
- Every living creature, the moment it is
born, reaches out for pleasure and rejoices in
it as the highest good, shrinks from pain as the
greatest evil, and, so far as it is able, averts
it from itself.
-
- Pleasure is the beginning and end of the
happy life.
Source: Volume 1 of The
Wisdom Seekers: Great Philosophers of the Western
World, by James L. Christian. If you want
an excellent and comprehensive history of
philosophy, the two volumes in this set are among
the best available. And I'm not just saying that
because Professor Christian is a personal
friend. I used his introductory textbook in
philosophy -- Philosophy:
An Introduction to the Art of Wondering -- when
I was teaching an introduction to philosophy course
many years ago. It is an excellent introduction.
J.D.
FOR THE
RECORD
1.
MEDIA: Mainstream Newspaper Stories Are Riddled
With Errors
Almost half of the news articles written and
published by major daily newspapers in the U.S.
contain one or more factual errors.
Furthermore, less than two percent of these
errors are corrected -- even when the errors are
reported to the paper.
Those are the shocking findings of a new study
by Scott R. Maier, an associate professor at the
University of Oregon's School of Journalism and
Communication.
Maier created a database of several thousand
locally-created news stories clipped from 10 major
U.S. metropolitan newspapers. No sports stories,
opinion pieces, columns, or reviews were included.
He then contacted key sources for the story and
asked for feedback on errors.
The study found 2,615 factual errors in 1,220
stories.
Slate magazine media critic Jack Shafer
notes: "Most of the errors detected were relatively
minor -- an incorrect title or a wrong age. But
this is small consolation given the preponderance
of errors documented by Maier and the alleged
failure of some newspapers to run a correction,
even after being asked."
The study's focus on minor errors was
deliberate, as such errors are easier to find than
more subjective, and controversial, ones. But
naturally, this study raises the question of what
other, larger errors and fallacies are being passed
off as the truth each day.
Sources:
Courtesy Of: Advocates
for Self-Government
2.
PSYCHOLOGY: Report - Liberals And Conservatives
Have Different Brains
It's a given that liberals and conservatives
think differently. Now research suggests that's
literally true.
According to a report in the journal Nature
Neuroscience, researchers at New York
University and UCLA found that political
orientation is related to differences in how the
brain deals with information.
The results indicate that "there are two
cognitive styles -- a liberal style and a
conservative style," UCLA neurologist Dr. Marco
Iacoboni, who was not involved in the research,
told the Los Angeles Times.
The researchers told college students -- whose
political orientation ranged from "very liberal" to
"very conservative" -- to tap a keyboard when an M
appeared on a computer screen, and not to tap when
a W appeared.
The letter M appeared four times more frequently
than W, so participants were conditioned to "press
a key in knee-jerk fashion whenever they saw a
letter," the Times explained.
Participants were wired to a device that
recorded activity in the part of the brain that
detects conflicts between a habitual tendency --
pressing a key when they saw a W -- and the
appropriate response, not pressing the key.
The results: Liberals had more brain activity
and made fewer mistakes than conservatives when
they saw a W, while the left-wing and right-wing
brains performed equally well in recognizing an
M.
Liberals were 4.9 times as likely as
conservatives to show activity in the brain
circuits that deal with conflicts, and 2.2 times as
likely to score in the top half of participants for
accuracy, according to Frank Sulloway, a researcher
at the University of California-Berkeley's
Institute of Personality and Social Research, who
analyzed the data but was not connected to the
research.
The Times reported: "Sulloway said the
results could explain why President Bush
demonstrated a single-minded commitment to the Iraq
war and why some people perceived Sen. John F.
Kerry . . . as a flip-flopper for changing his mind
about the conflict."
Source: http://www.latimes.com/features/health/la-sci-politics10sep10,1,3200056.story?ctrack=1&cset=true
Courtesy Of: NewsMax
Insider Report
3.
Short Takes
Bush - The Biggest Taxer and Spender In Human
History: "It seems safe to conclude that George
W. Bush will go down in history as the biggest
taxer and the biggest spender ever," says David
Boaz of the Cato Institute. Boaz, writing in Cato's
blog, notes that federal revenues reached the
incomprehensibly huge amount of $2.12 trillion
($2,120,000,000,0000) for the first ten months of
fiscal year 2007. That is, quite simply, the
largest amount any government in all of human
history has ever seized from taxpayers. And yet,
incredibly, Bush and Congress managed to spend even
more than that. Spending was $2.27 trillion for the
same ten months. The war in Iraq, while a
contributor, is not the root problem. Government
spending is simply running amok, Boaz notes, "on
everything from earmarks to entitlements to war."
Source: http://www.cato-at-liberty.org/2007/08/12/bush-the-biggest-taxer-in-world-history/
Ignorant Voters Decide Our Fate: "The
political knowledge of the average voter has been
tested repeatedly, and the scores are impressively
low. ... In polls taken since 1945, a majority of
Americans have been unable to name a single branch
of government, define the terms 'liberal' and
'conservative,' and explain what the Bill of Rights
is. ... More than two-thirds have reported that
they do not know the substance of Roe v. Wade and
what the Food and Drug Administration does. ..
Nearly half do not know that states have two
senators and three-quarters do not know the length
of a Senate term. ... More than fifty per cent of
Americans cannot name their congressman; forty per
cent cannot name either of their senators."
Source: "Fractured
Franchise" by Louis Menand, New Yorker
magazine
Film Schools Teach Wrong Copyright
Lesson: The University of Hawaii's Academy of
Creative Media claims that it is "more than just a
film school" because it seeks to "empower students
to tell their own stories of Hawaii" through film
and digital media. Too bad that empowerment stops
once the student has completed his or her project.
Taking a page from the University of Southern
California, UH is requiring film students to sign a
lengthy agreement assigning copyright in their
student works to the university. If students won't
sign, they are kicked out of their film production
classes. If they do sign, UH gets exclusive rights
to their work -- they can't sell it, rent it, show
or display it, copy it or make "derivative" works
from it. What is worse, UH won't even promise to
identify the student as the author of the work. As
Professor Larry Lessig points out, this theory
makes students into little more than artistic
sharecroppers. Why the draconian requirement? Find
out in EFF Staff Attorney Corynne McSherry's
complete post: http://www.eff.org/deeplinks/archives/005451.php.
Source: Electronic
Frontier Foundation (EFF). Article:
"On
Teaching Artists' Rights," by Lawrence
Lessig.
4.
Quote Of The Month
"The neo-cons claim surrender should not be an
option. In the same breath they claim we were
attacked because of our freedoms. Why then, are
they so anxious to surrender our freedoms with
legislation like the Patriot Act, a repeal of our
Fourth Amendment rights, executive orders, and
presidential signing statements? With politicians
like these, who needs terrorists? Do they think if
we destroy our freedoms for the terrorists they
will no longer have a reason to attack us? This
seems the epitome of cowardice coming from those
who claim a monopoly on patriotic courage." --
libertarian Congressman Ron Paul, "Surrender Should
Not Be An Option." Source: http://www.house.gov/paul/tst/tst2007/tst090207.htm
Please
Note: Items in the "For The Record" section do not
necessarily represent the views or opinions of The
Radical Academy. Nor is the Academy responsible for
any misrepresentation of the facts included. It is
your job to be a critical reader. We simply provide
this information as a service to our visitors
because we think it is interesting and/or
relevant.
COUNSELING
CORNER: A Valuable Lesson - God Works In Mysterious
Ways...
Come with me to a third grade classroom.....
There is a nine-year-old kid sitting at his desk
and all of a sudden, there is a puddle between his
feet and the front of his pants are wet. It's never
happened before, and he knows that when the boys
find out he will never hear the end of it. When the
girls find out, they'll never speak to him again as
long as he lives.
The boy believes his heart is going to stop; he
puts his head down and prays this prayer, "Dear
God, this is an emergency! I need help now! Five
minutes from now I'm dead meat."
He looks up from his prayer and here comes the
teacher with a look in her eyes that says he has
been discovered.
As the teacher is walking toward him, a
classmate named Susie is carrying a goldfish bowl
that is filled with water. Susie trips in front of
the teacher and inexplicably dumps the bowl of
water in the boy's lap.
The boy pretends to be angry, but all the while
is saying to himself, "Thank you, Lord! Thank you,
Lord!"
Now all of a sudden, instead of being the object
of ridicule, the boy is the object of sympathy. The
teacher rushes him downstairs and gives him gym
shorts to put on while his pants dry out. All the
other children are on their hands and knees
cleaning up around his desk. The sympathy is
wonderful.But as life would have it, the ridicule
that should have been his has been transferred to
someone else - Susie.
She tries to help, but they tell her to get out.
You've done enough, you klutz!"
Finally, at the end of the day, as they are
waiting for the bus, the boy walks over to Susie
and whispers, "You did that on purpose, didn't
you?"
Susie whispers back, "I wet my pants once
too."
The Lesson For Us: May God help us see
the opportunities that are always around us to do
good. Remember.....Just going to church doesn't
make you a Christian any more than standing in your
garage makes you a car. The wise person will say:
"I hope in the coming years there will be many
people with fish bowls around me!"
A
LITTLE OF THIS & A LITTLE OF
THAT
A Little Wisdom: "Please all, and you
will please none." -- Aesop (620-560 BC), Greek
storyteller.
A Little Advice: People are illogical,
inconsiderate and self-centred. Love them
anyway.
A Little Question: Why is it there are so
many more horses' asses than there are horses?
A Little Put-Down: The first sign of a
nervous breakdown is when you start thinking your
work is terribly important.
A Little Proverb: "Choose a job you like
and you will never have to work a day of your
life." -- Confucius.
A Little Reflection: Don't worry about
people stealing your ideas. If your ideas are that
good, you'll have to ram them down people's
throats.
A Little Definition: BEAUTY PARLOR
- A place where women curl up and dye.
A Little Quote: "I had a rose named after
me and I was very flattered. But I was not pleased
to read the description in the catalog: 'No good in
a bed, but fine against a wall.'" -- Eleanor
Roosevelt (1884-1962), First Lady of the United
States (1933-1945).
A Little Observation: If you pick up a
starving dog and make him prosperous, he will not
bite you. This is the principal difference between
a dog and a man.
A Little Quip: A journey of a thousand
miles begins with a cash advance.
ELSEWHERE
ON THE INTERNET
Some interesting & provocative articles
on other websites:
The
sorry state of science reporting, by Alan
Caruba: New technology drives out old
technology. As often as not, its impact is not
known until many years after its introduction.
Meanwhile, we live our lives day to day. This is
what is happening to the business of publishing
newspapers and magazines, places where,
traditionally, writers have earned a living.
Reflections
on Argumentation Ethics, by Michael S. Rozeff:
It is necessary by the nature of the subject matter
for me to make some preliminary disclaimers. If I
were to argue either for or against argumentation
ethics in this article, I would perhaps implicitly
be endorsing them merely by engaging in argument. I
say "perhaps" because this depends on what meaning
we attach to "argumentation" and what ethics we
suppose is presupposed when we engage in
argumentation.
An
Electronic Concentration Camp - Big Brother in the
Sky, by John Whitehead: Short of hiding out in
a cave, far removed from any trace of modern
technology, it would seem that there is no longer
any escaping the electronic concentration camp in
which we live.
The
God Delusion by Richard Dawkins - Mark Vernon
questions Richard Dawkins' state of
self-delusion: There is, I think, one good
thing about The God Delusion. Read as a
catalogue of religious excess and abuse and pulling
no punches, it serves a purpose. [Purchase
The
God Delusion, by Richard Dawkins through
The Radical Academy.]
The
sacred and the human, by Roger Scruton: Today's
atheist polemics ignore the main insight of the
anthropology of religion -- that religion is not
primarily about God, but about the human need for
the sacred. As René Girard argues, religion
is not the cause of violence, but the solution to
it.
Philosophical
Objections - Not Science - Guide Origin of Life
Research, by Casey Luskin: Michael Egnor
recently wrote about the great difficulties faced
by origin of life researchers and the great
speculation they are willing to undertake to retain
natural chemical explanations for origin of
life.
Philosophy
as a Way of Life, by Jules Evans: As we were
discussing last time, there is a movement in
philosophy at the moment to go beyond
postmodernism's emphasis on semiotics and ethical
relativism, to return to an idea of philosophy as
the practice of the 'Good Life'.
Do
science and rationality support atheism?: No,
says a nuclear physicist. To understand why, you
must be prepared to face the Fundamental Question
of Philosophy: Why is there anything rather than
nothing?
Articles
of Faith - Conflict between religion, science seems
everlasting, by Anthony B. Robinson: Who would
have thought that on a summer Saturday night in
Seattle a professor of philosophy could pack the
house?
Center
For Ethics Explores Wilderness And Environmental
Ethics: What does it mean to be 'natural'? How
did 19th century painters and writers shape
American fascination with rugged wilderness?
Secularists,
what happened to the open mind?, by Tom
Krattenmaker: Many of the leading voices among
atheists and the 'unreligious' reveal a disdain for
religion that can only damage today's dialogue.
Speaking with people of faith, instead of about
them, would enrich both sides of this philosophical
divide.
Plato
and the playful poets, by Jennie Erdal: It is
said that during Plato's long life no one ever saw
him smile. I can readily believe it. As preparation
for chairing an event at the Edinburgh Book
Festival I have been reacquainting myself with
Plato's Republic, the cornerstone of western
philosophy and a sober work.
The
Politics And Philosophy Of Harry Potter, by Prof.
Barry Rubin: Since the Harry Potter series is
so wildly and universally popular it is surprising
that there has not been more examination of its
sociology and cultural politics.
The
right to ridicule a religion, by Lars
Ströman: Artist Lars Vilks has made three
drawings ridiculing the prophet Mohammed. The
prophet is portrayed as a "roundabout dog". So far
three art exhibitions have declined to publish his
pictures.
If
Not Religion, What?, by Alan Contreras: In a
variety of arenas, from politics to high schools,
from colleges to the military, Americans argue as
though the proper face-to-face discussion in our
society ought to be between religion and
science.
Like
any half-decent atheist, I'm fond of a bit of
religion, by Magnus Linklater: Thank God I'm an
atheist. It's a big step to take, but it was
becoming difficult to cling to the agnostic
fig-leaf any longer.
|