|
Index for this
page...
All The Following Items Were Posted On April 1,
2008
FROM THE
MORTIMER ADLER FILE
Rights, Natural and Civil: The word
"rights" is a basic word in the vocabulary of
political science and political philosophy.
Civil or political rights are those included in
constitutions or in bills of rights. They are the
rights stated in the Constitution of the United
States, its amendments, and particularly in the
first ten amendments that are called our American
Bill of Rights.
These rights are either granted or not granted
by the state, and since they are within the power
of the state to grant, they can be countermanded by
the state when in the course of history fundamental
changes in policy are contemplated.
The ninth Amendment contains an implicit
reference to natural rights by declaring that "The
enumeration in the Constitution of certain rights
shall not be construed to deny or disparage others
retained by the people." Jurists who deny the
existence of natural rights think that this Ninth
Amendment is an unfortunate blemish in our
Constitution because it appears to be an
affirmation of natural rights.
Why? Because in 1793, when this amendment was
adopted, the other rights retained by the people
were probably the natural rights mentioned in the
second paragraph of the Declaration of
Independence, such as the inalienable rights to
life and liberty.
Natural rights are inherent in human nature.
They are, therefore, inalienable and belong to
every human being with no exceptions. They
are specifically human rights. Now that they have
become part of our government's declared foreign
policy, it becomes self-contradictory for legal
positivists to deny the existence of natural law
and natural rights, and yet to subscribe to our
government's foreign policy with regard to human
rights.
The exponents and defenders of natural and human
rights can argue that the existence of natural
rights derives from the distinction between needs
and wants -- or, what is the same, between natural
and acquired desires. Since human needs are the
needs inherent in human nature, identified by the
potentialities that define them, natural rights are
rights to the real goods that everyone needs in
order to live a morally good human life.
The statement in the Declaration of Independence
that all human beings have certain inalienable
rights can be expanded to say that these include
the right to life, the right to liberty, and the
right to whatever any human being needs in order to
live humanly well.
Natural rights can be violated or secured by
governments, but a perfectly just government is one
that secures and safeguards all natural and human
rights.
Source: Adler's
Philosophical Dictionary: 125 Key Terms for the
Philosopher's Lexicon. Have you a copy of
this book in your personal library? If not,
consider getting one. Read Max Weismann's review of
this book by Clicking
Here.
THE
PHILOSOPHERS SPEAK
Epictetus
(55-135), Ancient Greco-Roman moral
philosopher
"Epictetus had been a Phrygian slave belonging
to one of Nero's bodyguards; freed, he taught in
Rome till AD 90, when the emperor Domitian expelled
all philosophers from the city; after that he
taught at Nicopolis in northern Greece. Epictetus
addressed the masses rather than citizens of wealth
and culture, for it is the poor, he said, who are
in need of philosophy. Though he wrote nothing, his
lectures have been preserved through the notes of
one of his pupils, the historian Arrian." --
Professor James L. Christian. Read about Epictetus
in The Radical Academy.
- What is the first business of one who
practices philosophy? To get rid of
self-conceit. For it is impossible for anyone to
begin to learn that which he thinks he already
knows.
-
- To the rational being only the irrational is
unendurable.
-
- The good or will of man lies within his own
will.
-
- Apart from the will there is nothing good or
bad.
-
- No thing great is created suddenly, any more
than a bunch of grapes or a fig. If you tell me
that you desire a fig, I answer you that there
must be time. Let it first blossom, then bear
fruit, then ripen.
-
- First say to yourself what you would be; and
then do what you have to do.
-
- Seek not that the things which happen should
happen as you wish, but wish the things which
happen to be as they are, and you will have a
tranquil flow of life.
Source: Volume 1 of The
Wisdom Seekers: Great Philosophers of the Western
World, by James L. Christian. If you want
an excellent and comprehensive history of
philosophy, the two volumes in this set are among
the best available. And I'm not just saying that
because Professor Christian is a personal
friend. I used his introductory textbook in
philosophy -- Philosophy:
An Introduction to the Art of Wondering -- when
I was teaching an introduction to philosophy course
many years ago. It is an excellent introduction.
J.D.
FOR THE
RECORD
1.
Prison State USA: 1 in 100 Americans Now Behind
Bars, by James W. Harris
There has been an explosion in arrests and
imprisonment of Americans in recent years.
Today, for the first time in history, more than
one in every 100 American adults -- 2,319,258
persons -- is in jail or prison.
That's just one of the startling findings of a
new report by the respected Pew Center on the
States.
No other country on earth has as high a
percentage of citizens incarcerated. The runners-up
are China, Russia and several other former Soviet
bloc nations, sad company indeed.
Also, no other country in the world has so large
a number of its citizens behind bars. China, with a
larger population, allegedly has 1.5 million people
in prison. (Note: figures from authoritarian China
should always be viewed with suspicion.)
Black Americans are being hit particularly hard,
according to the report. "While one in 30 men
between the ages of 20 and 34 is behind bars, for
black males in that age group the figure is one in
nine."
According to the report, the high incarceration
rates have nothing to do with any increase in
crime. Instead, the rates reflect tougher
sentencing laws that have been passed in recent
years, such as "three-strikes" laws, that mandate
longer prison stays. Much of this, of course, is
due to the disastrous War on Drugs, which creates
incentives for property crimes and violent crimes
by creating a black market for drugs, and which
also spawned the "three-strike" type laws.
Indeed, as the libertarian magazine
Reason notes: "The problem is that [the
government] is locking up many people for
longer than is appropriate, and many people who do
not belong in prison at all, including nearly half
a million drug offenders."
Further, notes the Pew study: "The national
recidivism rate remains virtually unchanged, with
about half of released inmates returning to jail or
prison within three years."
In short, current incarceration policy seems to
be just like every other government program. It is
incredibly expensive, (last year states alone spent
more than $49 billion on corrections, up from $11
billion 20 years before), costs are skyrocketing,
it has unintended negative consequences, it is
milked by special interests, it victimizes utterly
innocent peaceful persons, and it largely doesn't
work.
Sources: Associated
Press; Pew
Study; Jacob
Sullum
-- James W. Harris is the editor of Liberator
Online, a publication of Advocates
for Self-Government. His articles have appeared
in numerous magazines and newspapers, and he has
been a Finalist for the Mencken Award, given by the
Free Press Association for "Outstanding Journalism
in Support of Liberty."
2.
Clinton Era Official Sees 'Global Power
Elite'
A former official in the Bill Clinton
administration says a "superclass" of 6,000
distinguished people from around the world
constitutes a "global power elite."
David Rothkopf served as Clinton's deputy
undersecretary of commerce for international trade.
He writes in his new book, "Superclass: The Global
Power Elite and the World They Are Making," that
these 6,000 have the power to get big things done
across national frontiers.
He includes the following in the group,
according to The Canadian Press:
- Heads of 120 governments that impact other
countries, by war or otherwise
- Commanders of the most powerful
militaries
- Key executives at 2,000 large corporations,
100 major financial institutions, and 500
investment firms
- Executives at international bodies, both
governmental and non-governmental
- Officials of the largest religious groups,
terrorist leaders, and criminal masterminds
- The most widely known bloggers, thinkers,
scientists, academics, and artists
The 6,000 have the power to acquire almost
anything they want -- except time, Rothkopf
maintains. That's why they spend so much time
traveling the world in private planes.
"For private jet travelers, globalization is not
an abstract concept by a day-to-day reality," he
writes. "Borders have disappeared and the world is
truly one global community.
But Rothkopf observes that this "superclass" is
not helping the 2 billion people who survive on $2
a day or less, and unless those 2 billion gain a
voice, globalization will be in danger.
Source: Insider
Report
3:
Short Takes
"Smoking bans can be hazardous to some people's
health. A rigorous statistical examination has
found that smoking bans increase drunken-driving
fatalities. One might expect that a ban on smoking
in bars would deter some people from showing up,
thereby reducing the number of people driving home
drunk. But jurisdictions with smoking bans often
border jurisdictions without bans, and some bars
may skirt the ban, so that smokers can bypass the
ban with extra driving. There is also a large
overlap between the smoker and alcoholic
populations, which would exacerbate the danger from
extra driving. The authors estimate that smoking
bans increase fatal drunken-driving accidents by
about 13 percent, or about 2.5 such accidents per
year for a typical county." Source:
Boston
Globe, "Uncommon Knowledge"
The Congressional Budget Office has released
costs of the Iraq and Afghanistan wars from 2001 to
present. Jim Harper of the Cato Institute analyzed
the figures. The results? "A little over $8,600 per
U.S. family, or $2,700 per person." And, of course,
rising. Source: Cato
Institute
"Airport security lines can annoy passengers,
but there is no evidence that they make flying any
safer, U.S. researchers reported... A team at the
Harvard School of Public Health could not find any
studies showing whether the time-consuming process
of X-raying carry-on luggage prevents hijackings or
attacks. They also found no evidence to suggest
that making passengers take off their shoes and
confiscating small items prevented any incidents."
TSA (the U.S. Transportation Security
Administration) defended their efforts by saying
they had confiscated over 13 million prohibited
items in one year. Most were... cigarette lighters.
Source: Reuters
4:
Quote of the Month
"Hard to believe Fidel Castro is gone. See? So,
the embargo worked; 49 years later, he is out of
there." -- Jay Leno, The Tonight Show, February
21.
COUNSELING
CORNER:
Warning
-- Beware of some fellow humans out there . .
.
(This is a collection of stories sent to us over
the past few months.)
We had to have the garage door repaired. The
Sears repairman told us that one of our problems
was that we did not have a "large" enough motor on
the opener. I thought for a minute, and said that
we had the largest one Sears made at that time, a
1/2 horsepower. He shook his head and said, "Lady,
you need a 1/4 horsepower." I responded that 1/2
was larger than 1/4. He said, "NO, it's not." Four
is larger than two.." -- At a Sears' repair
service.
My daughter and I went through the McDonald's
take-out window and I gave the clerk a $5 bill. Our
total was $4.25, so I also handed her a quarter.
She said, "you gave me too much money." I said,
"Yes I know, but this way you can just give me a
dollar bill back." She sighed and went to get the
manager who asked me to repeat my request. I did
so, and he handed me back the quarter, and said
"We're sorry but they could not do that kind of
thing." The clerk then proceeded to give me back $1
and 75 cents in change. -- A clerk at a
McDonalds.
My daughter went to a local Taco Bell and
ordered a taco. She asked the person behind the
counter for "minimal lettuce." He said he was
sorry, but they only had iceberg lettuce. -- A
clerk at a Taco Bell.
The stoplight on the corner buzzes when it's
safe to cross the street. I was crossing with an
intellectually challenged coworker of mine. She
asked if I knew what the buzzer was for. I
explained that it signals blind people when the
light is red. Appalled, she responded, "What on
earth are blind people doing driving?!" -- She was
a probation officer in Wichita , KS.
When my husband and I arrived at an automobile
dealership to pick up our car, we were told the
keys had been locked in it. We went to the service
department and found a mechanic working feverishly
to unlock the drivers side door. As I watched from
the passenger side, I instinctively tried the door
handle and discovered that it was unlocked. "Hey,"
I announced to the technician, "its open!" His
reply, "I know. I already got that side." -- At a
Ford dealership in Canton , Mississippi.
I work with an individual who plugged her power
strip back into itself and for the sake of her
life, couldn't understand why her system would not
turn on. -- A certain deputy with the Dallas County
Sheriffs office.
I live in a semi rural area. We recently had a
new neighbor call the local township administrative
office to request the removal of the DEER CROSSING
sign on our road. The reason: "Too many deer are
being hit by cars out here! I don't think this is a
good place for them to be crossing anymore." -- A
concerned resident in Kingman , KS.
I was at the airport, checking in at the gate
when an airport employee asked, "Has anyone put
anything in your baggage without your knowledge?"
To which I replied, "If it was without my
knowledge, how would I know?" He smiled knowingly
and nodded, "That's why we ask." -- Happened in
Birmingham , AL.
At a good-bye luncheon for an old and dear
coworker. She was leaving the company due to
"downsizing." Our manager commented cheerfully,
"This is fun. We should do this more often." Not
another word was spoken. We all just looked at each
other with that deer-in-the-headlights stare. --
This was a lunch at Texas Instruments.
SO BEWARE: They walk among us... and the scary
part is that they VOTE and they REPRODUCE.
A LITTLE
OF THIS & A LITTLE OF THAT
A Little Wisdom: "Don't worry about
avoiding temptation. . as you grow older, it will
avoid you." -- Winston Churchill.
A Little Advice: "By all means, marry. If
you get a good wife, you'll become happy; if you
get a bad one, you'll become a philosopher." --
Socrates
A Little Quip: "By the time a man is wise
enough to watch his step, he's too old to go
anywhere." -- Billy Crystal.
A Little Put-Down: "The secret of a good
sermon is to have a good beginning and a good
ending; and to have the two as close together as
possible." -- George Burns.
A Little Proverb: "Individuality is
freedom lived." -- John Dos Passos.
A Little Reflection: "One of the
penalties for refusing to participate in politics
is that you end up being governed by your
inferiors." -- Plato.
A Little Admission: "I was married by a
judge. I should have asked for a jury." -- Groucho
Marx.
A Little Quote: "When they call the roll
in the Senate, the senators do not know whether to
answer 'present' or 'guilty'." &emdash;Theodore
Roosevelt.
A Little Observation: "We could certainly
slow the aging process down if it had to work its
way through Congress." -- Will Rogers.
ELSEWHERE
ON THE INTERNET
Some interesting & provocative articles
on other websites:
Science
vs. Religion - The Ultimate Smackdown, by Lore
Sjöberg: If, like me, you are a mortal
human being living at this point in history, you
face an important decision: science or religion?
This is perhaps the most fundamental choice of
modern life, affecting every aspect of your daily
existence, from the smell of your house to whether
you would ever buy a book with "Chicken Soup" in
the title. And yet, few people have looked at this
decision from a practical angle. Most prefer
instead to focus on such ephemera as evidence
versus faith, or the likelihood of everlasting
life.
Philosophy
preparation for other fields, by Chase Rheam:
Philosophy graduate students go into fields of law
or teaching, among others, after they complete
their degree. Dr. James Cain, graduate adviser for
the department of philosophy, said law is probably
the biggest career field graduate students go into
after receiving their master's degree. "Philosophy
is supposed to be good preparation for law," Cain
said. "I guess because there is a lot of tight
argumentation."
Pupils
Probe Riddle of Life: Philosophy isn't a
subject you would expect to be a favourite with
young children.But a Dunvant Primary School teacher
is promoting a philosophy course in primary schools
across Swansea. Phil Jenkins is trained to run
mentoring programmes for other teachers. He said:
"Following a two-day training course in philosophy
for children, teachers are prepared to lead
communities of inquiry in their classrooms.
Science
fits well in God's plan - Day focuses on Catholic
men, by Bronislaus B. Kush: Modern science has
made such a thorough and compelling case for
explaining the universe's origins that renowned
physicist Stephen Hawking, in his best-seller "A
Brief History of Time," bluntly asked, "What place
then for a Creator?" Had the renowned British
theorist, known for his contributions to the fields
of cosmology and quantum gravity, been at the DCU
Center yesterday, he may have gotten a satisfactory
answer.
When
There Is Too Much Religion In Politics, by Deal W.
Hudson: What I mean by "too much religion in
politics" is what occurs when people of faith treat
their religious convictions as the end, rather than
the beginning, of the argument.
Science
and faith are not mutually exclusive, by Galen
Holley: In the Middle Ages there was a phrase
that largely summed up how people thought. It was
"Faith seeking understanding." Faith, in this age,
was the great, unassailable "given," the basis for
truth. Clearly, so the thinking went, God existed.
His exploits were there for us to read in the Bible
and, to the extent that it thought we needed to,
the church was there to tell us how to understand
him.
Taking
evidence seriously - Public policy decisions should
be based on evidence. So why are taxpayers funding
faith schools and alternative therapies?, by Alan
Sokal: "We're an empire now, and when we act,
we create our own reality," a senior adviser to
President Bush told the New York Times in the
summer of 2002. It might seem obvious that public
policy ought to be based on reality and evidence,
but the implications of taking seriously an
evidence-based worldview are far more radical than
most people realise.
Moral
thinking - Biology invades a field philosophers
thought was safely theirs: Whence morality?
That is a question which has troubled philosophers
since their subject was invented. Two and a half
millennia of debate have, however, failed to
produce a satisfactory answer. So now it is time
for someone else to have a go. And at a panel
discussion at the American Association for the
Advancement of Science meeting, a group of
biologists did just that.
Socrates
in the 21st Century - Is the endlessly examined
life still worth a look?, by Carlin Romano:
Given the choice between Socrates dead or alive,
Western thinkers have preferred him dead. At least
as a symbol. A symbol of what? That's where it gets
complicated. Almost all Western intellectuals
regard the life and death of Socrates (470-399 BC)
to be a cornerstone of cultural literacy.
|