|
Index for this
page...
All The Following Items Were Posted On May 1,
2009
FROM
THE MORTIMER ADLER FILE
State:
The word "state" is used loosely in everyone's
daily speech. It requires qualification for
philosophy's purposes.
Used loosely, it refers to any community of
individuals who live peaceably with one another for
their common good -- people who for the most part
are not related in any way by ties of blood or of
consanguinity. In this sense of the word, the fifty
states that are member of the American union are
states, and so too is the United States of
America.
However, the fifty states of the American union
are not properly called states, because they do not
have any external sovereignty; they cannot make war
and peace with foreign communities, they cannot
make alliances with them, or enter into treaties
with them.
Philosophically, a state can be said to exist
only when it is a community ruled by a person or
persons who hold public office or offices that are
defined by a constitution that the community has
formulated and ratified. Another word for such a
community, in which the rulers have no power vested
in them personally, but only in the offices to
which they have been elected or appointed, is a
"republic." In this sense of the term, a community
ruled by a king or despot is not a state.
Aristotle puts his finger on this point of
difference between communities that are and
communities that are not states in which the rulers
are either elected or appointed officeholders. The
citizens are those who rule and are ruled in turn
-- rulers when they are public officials and ruled
when they are returned to private life as citizens
no longer in office.
In ancient Greece the city (or polis) was
a state or republic. The word "citizen" drives its
meaning from that fact.
Only a person who is governed constitutionally
is properly called a citizen. If the
constitutionally governed communities of Greek
antiquity had been called "republics" instead of
"city-states," the word "republican" could have
been used instead of "citizen."
In the world today most of its population lives
under dictatorships, not in republics. A very small
percentage of the world's population lives in
states that are clearly republics.
Source: Adler's
Philosophical Dictionary: 125 Key Terms for the
Philosopher's Lexicon. Have you a copy of
this book in your personal library? If not,
consider getting one. Read Max Weismann's review of
this book by Clicking
Here.
THE
PHILOSOPHERS SPEAK
René
Descartes (1596-1650): French rationalist
philosopher
Descartes was a French philosopher and
mathematician. He proposed a dualistic philosophy
based on the separation of soul and body, mind and
matter, and sought to establish his system on
mathematics and pure reason. His most famous dictum
"Cogito ergo sum" is usually translated as
"I think, therefore I am." He also made important
contributions to the disciplines of mathematics and
astronomy.
- It is some time since I first realized how
many false opinions I accepted as true from my
childhood, and how doubtful was the entire
structure of thought which I had built upon
them. I therefore understood that I must, if I
wanted to establish anything at all in science
that was firm and liable to last, once and for
all rid myself of all the opinions I had
adopted, and start from an entire new
foundation. ...
-
- There is a vast difference between the mind
and body, in that the body by its very nature is
always divisible, while the mind is completely
indivisible. For when I consider the mind, or
rather when I consider myself simply as a
thinking thing, I find I can distinguish no
parts within myself, and I clearly discern that
I am a thing utterly one and complete. Although
my whole mind seems to be united to my whole
body, when a foot, or an arm, or any other part
is severed, I am not conscious of anything
having been removed from my mind. Nor can the
faculties of willing, perceiving,
conceptualizing, and so forth, in any way he
called parts of the mind, as it is always the
same mind which is doing the willing,
perceiving, conceptualizing, and so forth.
Meanwhile, utterly the opposite holds for all
corporeal or extended things. For I cannot
imagine any one of them which I cannot in my
thoughts easily split into parts, and thus I
understand that it is divisible.
Excerpted from Meditations, by
René Descartes. Read about René
Descartes in The Radical Academy. Books
by and about Rene Descartes. In the Classic
Philosophers: The
Philosophy of Rene Descartes.
FOR THE
RECORD
What
Makes Us Human?
Six years ago Katherine S. Pollard jumped at an
opportunity to join the international team that was
identifying the sequence of DNA bases, or
"letters," in the genome of the common chimpanzee
(Pan troglodytes). As a biostatistician with a
long-standing interest in human origins, she was
eager to line up the human DNA sequence next to
that of our closest living relative and take
stock.
A humbling truth emerged: our DNA blueprints are
nearly 99 percent identical to theirs. That is, of
the three billion letters that make up the human
genome, only 15 million of them--less than 1
percent--have changed in the six million years or
so since the human and chimp lineages diverged.
Evolutionary theory holds that the vast majority
of these changes had little or no effect on our
biology. But somewhere among those roughly 15
million bases lay the differences that made us
human. Pollard was determined to find them. Since
then, she and others have made tantalizing progress
in identifying a number of DNA sequences that set
us apart from chimps.
Source: Scientific
American
Writing
About Values Lifts Some Students'
Grades
Some seventh graders who were struggling in
class did significantly better after performing a
series of brief confidence-building writing
exercises, and the improvements continued through
eighth grade, researchers are reporting
Thursday.
The students who benefited most were blacks who
were doing poorly, the study found; the exercises
made no difference for whites, or for black
students who were already doing well. Experts
cautioned that the writing was hardly transforming:
Those who benefited were still barely getting C's,
on average, by the end of middle school.
Yet the results were surprising, because
interventions to improve school performance tend to
have short-term benefits, and the writing
assignments were simple, 15-minute efforts. ... The
study was published in the journal
Science.
Source: New
York Times
Wired
for Wisdom
Across time and cultures, humans have extolled
the virtues of self-understanding, emotional
stability, compassion, morality and empathy for
others.
These are, it's said, the universal traits of
wisdom, valued everywhere. Which got two
researchers at the University of California San
Diego thinking: Is there a neurobiological basis
for wisdom? Is being wise all about wiring?
Writing in the current issue of the Archives
of General Psychiatry, Dr. Dilip Jeste, chief
of geriatric psychiatry at UCSD, and Dr. Thomas
Meeks, an assistant clinical professor of
psychiatry, say the answer might be yes. They have
proposed a "speculative" model that suggests wisdom
combines portions of the brain's older limbic
system, a region governing emotional behavior, with
the prefrontal cortex, a more recently evolved part
of the brain associated with reasoning,
decision-making and value judgment.
Source: San
Diego Union-Tribune
Found:
The Brain's Centre of Wisdom
Scientists have identified the seat of human
wisdom by pinpointing parts of the brain that guide
us when we face difficult moral dilemmas.
Sophisticated brain scanning techniques have
found that humans respond by activating areas
associated with the primitive emotions of sex, fear
and anger as well as our capability for abstract
thought.
The findings, to be published in the Archives
of General Psychiatry, represent a significant
incursion into territory once regarded as the
domain of religion and philosophy.
Source: The
(London) Times
Near-Death
Experiences: Heaven Can Wait
When doctors returned to check on the patient
who had almost died and been in a deep coma before
being resuscitated, he thanked them for all the
work they had done. He had, he told the surprised
team of medics, been very impressed and had watched
everything they had done. He had heard all that had
been said, too .... He then went on to describe in
detail the room where he had been treated--although
he had never been conscious in there.
That near-death experience is one of a number
recorded by Dutch doctors and one of thousands of
similar cases that have now been documented in a
major worldwide study.
New research shows that many critically ill
kidney dialysis patients have similar experiences,
and that almost one in 10 heart-arrest survivors
also report near-death experiences whose features
include out of body sensations, bright lights, dark
tunnels, and images of life events and spiritual
entities.
Source: The
Independent (UK)
Commentary:
Why Science Doesn't Make Sense
Wouldn't it be great if science was a cool,
logical process? If you could work out how the
universe ticks without making the chilling
discovery that most of it is missing? Or if, when
you were investigating the placebo effect, you
didn't find that some licensed drugs only work when
you know you're taking them?
Unfortunately, as these examples show, things
don't often work as neatly as scientists might
like. Doing science is messy and difficult - and
that's before you factor in its human side. Jealous
rivals, journal editors who think your subject is a
joke, or colleagues with a lot to lose if your
latest discovery pans out: other people can all
make the scientific life a difficult one.
... In science, it was ever thus; progress is
far harder-won than you might imagine. Experimental
anomalies are often the things that expose the
shortcomings of contemporary thinking--so you might
imagine that they would be greeted with delight.
Yet the opposite is usually true: the things that
don't make sense are often the downfall of any
scientists who embrace them.
Source: The
Telegraph (UK)
Inside
the Baby Mind
What is it like to be a baby? For centuries,
this question would have seemed absurd: behind that
adorable facade was a mostly empty head. A baby,
after all, is missing most of the capabilities that
define the human mind, such as language and the
ability to reason.
Rene Descartes argued that the young child was
entirely bound by sensation, hopelessly trapped in
the confusing rush of the here and now. A newborn,
in this sense, is just a lump of need, a bundle of
reflexes that can only eat and cry. To think like a
baby is to not think at all.
Modern science has largely agreed, spending
decades outlining all the things that babies
couldn't do because their brains had yet to
develop. They were unable to focus, delay
gratification, or even express their desires. ...
Now, however, scientists have begun to dramatically
revise their concept of a baby's mind.
Source: Boston
Globe
5
Years After: Portugal's Drug Decriminalization
Policy Shows Positive Results
In the face of a growing number of deaths and
cases of HIV linked to drug abuse, the Portuguese
government in 2001 tried a new tack to get a handle
on the problem--it decriminalized the use and
possession of heroin, cocaine, marijuana, LSD and
other illicit street drugs.
The theory: focusing on treatment and prevention
instead of jailing users would decrease the number
of deaths and infections.
Five years later, the number of deaths from
street drug overdoses dropped from around 400 to
290 annually, and the number of new HIV cases
caused by using dirty needles to inject heroin,
cocaine and other illegal substances plummeted from
nearly 1,400 in 2000 to about 400 in 2006,
according to a report released recently by the Cato
Institute, a Washington, D.C, libertarian think
tank.
Source: Scientific
American
A
LITTLE OF THIS & A LITTLE OF
THAT
A Little Wisdom: "The civilized man has a
moral obligation to be skeptical, to demand the
credentials of all statements that claim to be
facts." -- Bergan Evans
A Little Advice: "To find a friend one
must close one eye -- to keep him, two." -- Norman
Douglas
A Little Quip: "If I have any beliefs
about immortality, it is that certain dogs I have
known will go to heaven, and very, very few
persons." -- James Thurber
A Little Proverb: "It is easier to fight
for one's principles than to live up to them." --
Alfred Adler
A Little Question: "Why do you sit there
looking like an envelope without any address on
it?" -- Mark Twain
A Little Reflection: "He can compress the
most words into the smallest idea of any man I
know." -- Abraham Lincoln
A Little One-Liner: "He has no enemies,
but is intensely disliked by his friends." -- Oscar
Wilde
A Little Admission: "I didn't attend the
funeral, but I sent a nice letter saying I approved
of it." -- Mark Twain
A Little Observation: "Some cause
happiness wherever they go; others whenever they
go." -- Oscar Wilde
A Little Warning: "If you can't be a good
example, then you'll just have to be a horrible
warning." -- Catherine Aird
A Little Quote: "He has all the virtues I
dislike and none of the vices I admire." -- Winston
Churchill
A Little Politics: "I love a dog. He does
nothing for political reasons." -- Will Rogers
|