|
July
8, 2009
Bill
Marina, Libertarian Historian
by Gary North, Ph.D.
Bill
Marina (1937-2009) died of a heart attack on the
morning of July 7. The libertarian movement has
lost one of its most gifted historians. He was
retired from teaching, but he was the least retired
retired professor I have ever known. He was working
on half a dozen major projects when he died.
My main regret is that he did not write more
books. But he wrote essays and short items
constantly, including one posted a couple of hours
before he died: an essay on Israeli
"sovereignty" (his quotation marks) and American
power.
He was the author of the standard college-level
textbook on the history of Florida. That was his
only book that ever sold well. He was a
non-interventionist in his view of American foreign
policy. He began his academic career with a 1968
Ph.D. dissertation: Opponents of Empire: An
Interpretation of American Anti-Imperialism,
1898-1921. Sadly, it was never published. With
the Web, I hope the actual dissertation will be. He
had recently bought a book-scanning machine that
will create PDFs. He wanted to re-publish classic
books and post them on the Web.
He never deviated from his opposition to empire.
He took
shots at it whenever he could find an outlet.
He is the only person I ever knew who thought
George Washington was a closet imperialist. He
wrote this in a LRC
article in 2007.
- Much has been made by some opponents of
Interventionism, in suggesting that we go back
to Washington's Farewell Address, of "no
entangling alliances," as a model for the
country today. I believe this a misreading of
the Washington-Alexander Hamilton view, that
this really meant an open door to unilateral
intervention.
-
- As exhibit one, I would offer Washington's
aid to the French Creoles in Haiti in 1792, in
an effort to thwart the Blacks revolting there.
Here was America's first effort at "foreign
aid," some $726,000 at a time when that was real
money! As a southerner and slaveholder,
Washington was concerned that Black revolt would
carry over into the United States.
Bill Marina was hard-core.
He wrote a series of articles three decades ago
on the militia in the American Revolution. The
local militias, not Washington's centralized
conventional army, held the British in check inside
coastal cities. He wrote
this in 1975:
- The regular American army, as well as
segments of a rag-tag militia, accepted the
surrender at Yorktown. The existence of that
army should never be allowed to obscure the
large reason for the British defeat which was
that they could never control, let alone win
over, a population of armed militia that was the
foundation of support for the American
government. The British military historian Eric
Robson acknowledged: "Restricted to little more
than the ground they stood on, the British
increasingly found subsistence a matter of
considerable difficulty." That was not the
result of Washington's valiant little army
camped at Valley Forge or for so many years
across the Hudson from the British in New York
City, but rather the American guerrilla militia
that from local homes and farms made life in the
British Army a living hell. Every small
detachment was legitimate prey for the
Americans. Historians will never know how many
of these small skirmishes there were, but only
glimpse them all over the landscape, realizing
that they form the real reason for the low
British morale and eventual defeat.
I earned a Ph.D. in American history, with a
concentration in colonial America. Before I read
Marina, I had never heard this story. It is still
ignored in the textbooks. This was the origin of
the Second Amendment.
I knew nothing of his heart condition, but I was
concerned that he would not finish his great book,
a detailed analysis of the Kennedy assassination.
He was the only history professor who was in Dealey
Plaza at the moment it happened. He was on the
faculty of the University of Texas, Arlington, at
the time. He spent over 40 years studying the
event, and having his students study it. He was
convinced that Oswald acted alone.
His death is unnerving for me, because a week
ago, I wrote an article about a
letter I sent to him on how to market his book,
when he finished it.
In late April, I wrote an
article just for him, to encourage him to
finish. I wrote this:
- It is steady as you go. It is line upon
line. It is cumulative. If you are working on
several projects, be sure that you have a
schedule to complete each one in sequence. Stick
to your schedule. If you don't, you will
probably die with all of them incomplete and
fragmentary.
-
- So, you must prioritize. Be in a position to
reschedule your time, so that if you ever find
out you are terminal, you can complete the main
one. This means that you must steadily complete
sections of the main one. Get them finished.
Don't assume that you have 20 years.
My worst fear has been realized.
I will miss him personally. I will miss his
intellect. I am happy that just a few days ago, I
asked him for recommendations of books on
Confucius. He was also an expert in Chinese
history. He sent me three suggestions.
I should have asked for a lot more suggestions
over the years.
Gary
North Archive
Dr.
Gary North earned a Ph.D. in history and is one of
America's keenest economic analysts and
commentators. He supports the Austrian school of
economics and is a previous assistant to
libertarian congressman Dr. Ron Paul. Visit his
website at http://garynorth.com.
To
subscribe to Gary North's Reality Check go to
http://www.dailyreckoning.com/sub/GetReality.cfm
If
you enjoyed this essay and would like to read more
of Gary's writing please visit his website at
http://www.garynorth.com
or http://www.freebooks.com
Articles
& Essays Index
Because
The Radical Academy publishes essays and articles
on its website does not imply acceptance or
approval of the comments or opinions expressed by
the author of the material. Nor is the Academy
responsible for any misrepresentation of the facts
included. It is your job to be a critical
reader.
|