|
October
22, 2008
Too Big to
Fail?
by Rep. Ron Paul, MD
In
the midst of highly unpopular bailouts of Wall
Street, many justifications have been given about
why Washington feels the need to act. Some claim
that capitalism and the free market are to blame,
but we have not had capitalism. If you compare our
financial capital to our aggregate debt, this would
be obvious. In the same way, we have not had a
truly free market. The monetary manipulations of
the Federal Reserve, a complex tax code, the many
"oversight" agencies and their mountains of
regulations show that we are far removed from a
free market economy.
Another unsatisfying argument is that certain
entities have to be bailed out because of their
economic importance. Supposedly, some entities can
be so big, so important, that no matter what they
do, citizens must perpetually sustain them.
Even limited government has a basic duty to
defend against force and fraud. Some argue that
force is somehow permissible just because the
entity engaging in it is "economically
significant." But one could use this reasoning to
prop up slavery. It could be deemed unfortunate but
economically beneficial, and indeed these arguments
have been used historically to deprive people of
their liberty. But slavery should never be
tolerated regardless of any economic benefit, just
as systemic fraud should not be tolerated. Some
banks on Wall Street should fail. Fannie and
Freddie should fail. They are perpetrating fraud
against the people. Yet, government insists on
rewarding behavior which should instead be
investigated, prosecuted, and punished.
There has been much evidence of fraud at Fannie
and Freddie, but when one man, Franklin Raines,
defrauded the organization out of millions of
dollars through illegal accounting tricks, and ends
up agreeing to pay back just a fraction, one could
argue that it was well worth it to him. Fannie went
on to only get more deeply involved in subprime
mortgages after this investigation. Several
organizations are suffering right now precisely
because the free market is trying to work and
punish mismanagement, if only the government would
get out of the way and let it. Perhaps banks are
not lending to each other because they know that
complicated accounting standards, created in part
to defend against confiscatory tax policy, enables
false fiscal pictures to be presented, which erodes
trust. But this is not a time for the government to
step in with more burdensome and complicated
regulations, or more foolish liquidity injections.
This is a time for some banks to fail, and
remaining banks to deal honestly and transparently
once again. More regulations will only result in
more lies.
Just as economies that turned away from slave
labor had a transition period, our economy would
transition as well, but in the end, if we turned to
honest, sound money and a truly free market, we
would end up with a more just society, founded on
truthfulness and decency, not subject to the
violence of force or the whims of fraudulent
institutions. Unfortunately, it seems we are headed
into a new era of slavery, however, where all
taxpayers will be forced to render to the Fed and
big banking interests the bulk of the fruits of
their labor, possibly through higher taxes but
definitely through the eroding force of
inflation.
Paul
Archive
Dr. Ron Paul is a Republican
member of Congress from Texas.
Because
The Radical Academy publishes essays and articles
on its website does not imply acceptance or
approval of the comments or opinions expressed by
the author of the material. Nor is the Academy
responsible for any misrepresentation of the facts
included. It is your job to be a critical
reader.
Enrich
Your Life With A Book About Politics & Current
Events
Enrich
Your Life With A Politics & Current Events
Magazine
|
Academy
Showcase Specials
|
|
|
|
|
|
|